Long Pond & Monymusk Myers's Original Dark
Long Pond & Monymusk Myers's Original DarkMolasses-heavy Jamaican mixer, not a sipper
Tap a filter and we'll show you the matching bottles below.
Ranked by community score, available bottles first.
Long Pond & Monymusk Myers's Original DarkMolasses-heavy Jamaican mixer, not a sipper
Myers's Planter's Punch Brand Old Jamaica RumExplore our complete collection. Filter by price, rating, distillery, age, and more to find your perfect rum.
Long Pond & Monymusk Myers's Original DarkMolasses-heavy Jamaican mixer, not a sipper
Myers's Planter's Punch Brand Old Jamaica Rum
Myers's Single Barrel (Finished in Sazerac Rye Oak Casks)
Myers's Planter's Punch
Fred L. Myers and Son Myers's Gold Label Light Trewlany
Myers's Platinum White Fine Old Jamaica Rum
Myers's Legend Old Jamaica Rum
Myers's Planter's Punch 1970s
Myers's Demerara Navy Rum
Fred L. Myers and Son Myers's Signature Cask Collection (William Larue Weller Cask)
Myers's Planter's Punch 1960s
Myers's Planter's Punch 100% Fine Old Jamaica
Myers's Rum Golden Rich
Fred L. Myers and Son Myers's Signature Origin Collection (The Guyana Blend)
Fred L. Myers and Son Myers's Signature Cask Collection (Thomas H. Handy Sazerac Rye Cask)
Myers's Planter's Punch Brand Old Jamaica Rum 1940s
Fred L. Myers and Son Myers's Signature Cask Collection (George T.Stagg. Cask)
Fred L. Myers and Son Myers's Signature Cask Collection (Eagle Rare Cask)
Fred L. Myers and Son Myers's Signature Legends Collection The Legacy Blend (Blend N°1)
Fred L. Myers and Son Myers's Signature Cask Collection (Sazerac Rye Cask)Try adjusting your search criteria or clearing some filters.
Which bottling is the better one is decided neither by price nor by the age on the label. Here they stand side by side, sorted by the community's median rating. The number of ratings sits next to it: a high score from few voices says less than a middling one from many.
| Bottling | Age | ABV | Community score | Price |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Long Pond & Monymusk Myers's Original Dark Pot & Column Still Rum | 4 years | 40% | 6.0/10 111 reviews | 12 € |
| Myers's Planter's Punch Brand Old Jamaica Rum | — | 40% | 6.0/10 15 reviews | 15 € |
Only bottlings with at least 10 ratings are included. Anything below that is not a sound basis for comparison.
369 bottles from Myers's bought by the community.
as of
Myers’s is a Jamaican blend most people first meet through the Original Dark: a molasses-heavy, woody pour that shows up in Mai Tais and Planter’s Punch far more than in tasting glasses. The range runs from that dark workhorse and a Platinum White through Planter’s Punch bottlings, a Gold Label light Trelawny, and more recent Single Barrel releases finished in bourbon and rye casks.
Across 158 community reviews the median sits at 6.0/10, which tells the honest story. Several drinkers call the Original Dark good value at its price and a reliable cocktail base, while others find the standard bottlings thin, sweetened, and too smoky to sip neat. The single-barrel finishes earn a bit more respect as sippers.
RumX’s 0–10 scale is strict: 6.0 sits in the “Pleasant” band. 13% of tasters rate it Good or better; only 22% rate it below average. See the full rating guide →
Love rums from Myers's? The journey doesn't stop here. Download the RumX app to explore an even more extensive selection of rums from Myers's and around the world. With features like collection management, personalized recommendations, tasting notes, and a bustling community of rum enthusiasts, our free app offers the ultimate rum experience, right in your pocket.