
Buy The Real McCoy
7.7/10
443 reviews- A good fit if you like spicy rums and you’re just getting into rum
- Probably not if you’ve already tried a lot of rum
Foursquare-distilled Barbados rum, unsweetened and named for a Prohibition rum runner
The Real McCoy is a Barbados brand distilled at Foursquare, named after Bill McCoy, the Prohibition-era smuggler who ran unadulterated rum to New York. The lineup spans a 3 Year and 5 Year aimed at mixing, a 12 Year sipper, and limited editions finished in Madeira or virgin oak, plus higher-proof releases like Prohibition Tradition and Distiller’s Proof. Nothing here carries added sugar.
Across 440 community reviews the range sits at a median of 7.7/10. The recurring verdict is honest and consistent: these are clean, approachable Foursquare rums with vanilla, coconut and caramel, often described as a gentle way into the distillery. Several drinkers also note they lack the complexity of Foursquare’s premium ECS bottlings.
The Real McCoy: all bottlings and prices
10 bottlings, prices from 40 partner shops. As of November 2026.
Prices incl. VAT and shipping to incl. VAT & shipping to How we rank
By default, what matches your search and filters comes first. Where the match is equal, the rums currently most popular on RumX come first, then those with more ratings. The “Sort” menu shows which order applies and lets you sort by score, number of ratings or price.
Foursquare The Real McCoy 5 Years
Foursquare The Real McCoy Limited Edition Rum (Virgin Oak) 2017
Foursquare The Real McCoy Prohibition Tradition
Foursquare The Real McCoy 12 Years
Foursquare The Real McCoy 3 Years
Foursquare The Real McCoy Distiller's Proof Rum
Foursquare The Real McCoy 5 Years
Foursquare The Real McCoy Limited Edition Rum (Madeira Cask)
Foursquare The Real McCoy 14 Years Limited Edition
Change your search or remove some filters.
Is it your taste?
Is The Real McCoy a good rum?
The Real McCoy wins the community over: 86% of 443 ratings are good or better.
- you like spicy rums Share of ratings, distinctly spicy in community tags 79% all rums: 25%
- you’re just getting into rum Share of ratings for beginner bottles Exception: Foursquare The Real McCoy Prohibition Tradition 89% all rums: 30%
- you like plenty of oak Share of ratings, lots of oak in community tags 32% all rums: 12%
- you’ve already tried a lot of rum Share of ratings for connoisseur bottles 0% all rums: 49%
- you like it strong Share of ratings for bottles at 50% ABV or cask strength Exception: Foursquare The Real McCoy Prohibition Tradition 10% all rums: 54%
Buying for someone else? The Rum Finder helps you choose
Based on 443 ratings, including 99 with a flavour profile and 114 with a written review. Compared with all rums on RumX.
Which bottle?
Which The Real McCoy is the best?
Among rums with at least 30 ratings, Foursquare The Real McCoy Prohibition Tradition leads with 8.0/10 from 45 ratings. The most rated is Foursquare The Real McCoy 12 Years with 7.6/10 from 132. 6 of the 10 bottlings with a known strength are 46% ABV; the strongest is Foursquare The Real McCoy Prohibition Tradition at 50%.
All The Real McCoy expressions at a glance
| Bottling | Age | ABV | Rating | Priceincl. shipping |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Foursquare The Real McCoy 14 Years Limited Edition | 14 years | 46% | 8.1/10 (13 reviews) | not available |
| Foursquare The Real McCoy Prohibition Tradition Pot & Column Still Rum | 12 years | 50% | 8.0/10 (45 reviews) | 90.30 € 114.86 € per litre |
| Foursquare The Real McCoy Distiller's Proof Rum Pot & Column Still Rum | 12 years | 46% | 8.0/10 (10 reviews) | 67.58 € 88.11 € per litre |
| Foursquare The Real McCoy 5 Years Column Still Rum | 5 years | 46% | 8.0/10 (4 reviews) | 56.69 € 62.56 € per litre |
| Foursquare The Real McCoy Limited Edition Rum (Madeira Cask) Pot & Column Still Rum | 12 years | 46% | 7.9/10 (59 reviews) | not available |
| Foursquare The Real McCoy 12 Years Column Still Rum | 12 years | 46% | 7.9/10 (34 reviews) | 81.80 € 95.43 € per litre |
| Foursquare The Real McCoy Limited Edition Rum (Virgin Oak) 2017 Pot & Column Still Rum | 10 years | 46% | 7.7/10 (58 reviews) | 66.50 € 86.57 € per litre |
| Foursquare The Real McCoy 12 Years Pot & Column Still Rum | 12 years | 40% | 7.6/10 (132 reviews) | 58.85 € 74.14 € per litre |
| Foursquare The Real McCoy 5 Years Pot & Column Still Rum | 5 years | 40% | 7.1/10 (60 reviews) | 40.85 € 48.43 € per litre |
| Foursquare The Real McCoy 3 Years Pot & Column Still Rum | 3 years | 40% | 6.4/10 (28 reviews) | 34.90 € 42.71 € per litre |
The table lists 9 of the 10 bottlings on RumX, the ones with at least 10 ratings. Key bottlings are listed even with fewer ratings.
How the community rates The Real McCoy
The Real McCoy in the community's collections
522 of 753 bottles are still sealed.
- 522 sealed
- 117 open
- 114 emptied
15 were added in the last three months.
- 753 bottles on the shelf
- 443 reviews
- 10 different rums
Reported by RumX members from their collections · as of
Frequently asked questions about The Real McCoy
Free on iOS and Android.
