
The Auditor Reviews
1,400+ rum reviews and spirits across the board
Reviews by The Auditor Reviews
Hampden Kill Devil (The Whisky Barrel) C<>H 2007
Hampden Kill Devil (The Whisky Barrel) C<>H 2007Explosive high-ester Hampden fruit bomb
Cañada Alambique Serrano "Cartier 30"
Cañada Alambique Serrano "Cartier 30"Wild, salty, floral cane bomb
"What an impressive rum, packed full of minerality, fruits, and a touch of vinegar. It drinks well under its proof and the finish lasts an impressive amount of time. This is one of the top unaged rums …"
Velier Foursquare Sassafras 2006
Velier Foursquare Sassafras 2006Intense cognac-aged Foursquare powerhouse
Hampden Great House (Distillery Edition 2023)
Hampden Great House (Distillery Edition 2023)Balanced, fruity, approachable Hampden funk
Velier Papalin Jamaica High Esters 2019
Velier Papalin Jamaica High Esters 2019Funky, fruity value Jamaican blend
Foursquare ECS XXVI Magisterium 2008
Foursquare ECS XXVI Magisterium 2008Creamy sherried Foursquare with serious depth
"This is a great rum, it falls in that vein of Raspberry menthol cough syrup, but not as intense as others in that flavor vein that Ive had. Nevertheless, this is a great and tasty rum"
La Maison Du Whisky MHOBA Rum South Africa Flag Series (Collection Foundations) 2019
La Maison Du Whisky MHOBA Rum South Africa Flag Series (Collection Foundations) 2019Bold funky Mhoba at full power
"As a big fan of rums from Mhoba this one knocks it out of the park. Its bold, pungent, fruity, savory, briney, and just has a lot going on. The flavors play well together, which is good as I was …"
Monte Negro Grogue Barbosa Amado & Vicente
Monte Negro Grogue Barbosa Amado & VicenteWild, funky grogue for adventurous palates
Bologne Grande Savane Rhum Bio 2021
Bologne Grande Savane Rhum Bio 2021Fresh, salty, high‑proof agricole
"Nez : Citron, concombre, minéralité, cantaloup, sel de mer. Bouche : Bouche épaisse et huileuse, cantaloup, citron, minéralité, sel de mer, concombre, poivré, miellat, lavande. Finale : Longue …"
Bellevue Kill Devil (The Whisky Barrel) 1998
Bellevue Kill Devil (The Whisky Barrel) 1998Intense, smoky-fruity Bellevue standout
Habitation Velier Clarendon Selected for the USA EMB 2014
Habitation Velier Clarendon Selected for the USA EMB 2014Roaming Road Spirits Dominican Republic Rum
Roaming Road Spirits Dominican Republic RumHampden Pure Single Jamaican Rum Classic HLCF 2017
Hampden Pure Single Jamaican Rum Classic HLCF 2017Funky, punchy Hampden ester bomb
Velier Papalin Haiti 2018
Velier Papalin Haiti 2018Accessible, characterful Haitian clairin blend
Velier Hampden Pagos Sherry (Batch 2) 2023
Velier Hampden Pagos Sherry (Batch 2) 2023Funky Hampden meets rich sherry fruit
Foursquare ECS XXIV 2011
Foursquare ECS XXIV 2011Dry, powerful classic Foursquare ECS
South Pacific RA Fiji Rum FSDP 2001
South Pacific RA Fiji Rum FSDP 2001Herbal, woody, very atypical Fiji
The Wild Parrot Hampden Exclusively Bottled for Sansibar DOK 2009
The Wild Parrot Hampden Exclusively Bottled for Sansibar DOK 2009Wild DOK funk at full power
Holmes Cay Savanna Réunion Island Grand Arôme Rum No. 3 2023
Holmes Cay Savanna Réunion Island Grand Arôme Rum No. 3 2023Wild, briny funk bomb
Hampden Kill Devil (The Whisky Barrel) 2001
Hampden Kill Devil (The Whisky Barrel) 2001Relaxed, dry high‑ester Hampden
"Hampden is my favorite distillery and we see no surprise here this is another great example of why. Great flavors, that classic pineapple, a bit of glue. Just a real funky rum that has been tamped a …"
Bologne Le Distillat (100% Canne Noire) 2022
Bologne Le Distillat (100% Canne Noire) 2022Explosive, vegetal agricole power
"Nose: Bright, Lemongrass, minerality, sea salt, rainwater, grapefruit, lime peel Palate: Thick oily mouthfeel, grapefruit, sea salt, lime peel, lemongrass, sea salt, earthy Finish: Medium length …"
St. Nicholas Abbey 5 Years old Single Cask
St. Nicholas Abbey 5 Years old Single CaskSpicy, citrusy Barbados cask-strength sipper
"Nose: Vanilla, Grapefruit, Toasted Coconut Flakes, orange peel Palate: Thick oily mouthfeel, touch of oil, grapefruit, toasted coconut, orange peel, Mango, cola Finish: Long Finish, Grapefruit, Oil, …"
Whisky & Rhum Port Mourant L‘Esprit 2005
Whisky & Rhum Port Mourant L‘Esprit 2005Bedford Park Mount Gay Single Barrel Barbados Rum (Saint Michael) 2001
Bedford Park Mount Gay Single Barrel Barbados Rum (Saint Michael) 2001Caroni Kill Devil (The Whisky Barrel) HTR 1998
Caroni Kill Devil (The Whisky Barrel) HTR 1998"Of the Caroni casks that The Whisky Barrel had at one point, this is the best of them. This is a great example of what good Caroni can be, a mix of pleasant fruit flavors balanced out by those …"
Holmes Cay Clarendon Jamaica EMB EMB 2014
Holmes Cay Clarendon Jamaica EMB EMB 2014Velier Hampden Trelawny Endemic Birds (Becard) LFCH 2011
Velier Hampden Trelawny Endemic Birds (Becard) LFCH 2011Faraday Saint James Redux Limited Release West Indies Rum 2018
Faraday Saint James Redux Limited Release West Indies Rum 2018Havana Club Selección de Maestros
Havana Club Selección de MaestrosBalanced, woody Cuban allrounder
Bellevue Kill Devil (The Whisky Barrel) 1998
Bellevue Kill Devil (The Whisky Barrel) 1998Complex smoky Bellevue heavyweight
"This is a very good rum. It has those notes I like in really old rums, that nuttiness, a bit of star anise, some fruits. However, compared to other rums in this style, it feels a bit watered down. It …"
La Maison Du Whisky Distillerie d’Indochine Rum Vietnam Flag Series (Collection Foundations) 2018
La Maison Du Whisky Distillerie d’Indochine Rum Vietnam Flag Series (Collection Foundations) 2018Dry, cognac-kissed Vietnamese agricole surprise
"This is a very good rum. The dark chocolate flavor really pops out, as does the ginger and brine. The Raspberry is prominent as well. This is good, but the cask dominates the base distillate a little …"
Caroni Kill Devil (The Whisky Barrel) HTR 1998
Caroni Kill Devil (The Whisky Barrel) HTR 1998Big, oily, classic tarry Caroni
"This is a very good rum. It’s certainly better than the other 1998 Caroni I tried recently, but it doesn’t quite live up to the more exceptional"
Holmes Cay Savanna Réunion Island Rum Traditionnel No. 4 2025
Holmes Cay Savanna Réunion Island Rum Traditionnel No. 4 2025La Maison Du Whisky Rum Saint Lucia (Flag Series) 2004
La Maison Du Whisky Rum Saint Lucia (Flag Series) 2004Dry, medicinal, woody St. Lucia power
Renegade Pre-Cask Nursery (Upper La Calome) 2022
Renegade Pre-Cask Nursery (Upper La Calome) 2022Grassy, vegetal Renegade mixer
"Bouquet: Schwache Zitronenschalen, Salzlake, leicht vegetabil Gaumen: Mittleres Mundgefühl, pflanzlich, Zitronenschalen, Salzlake Abgang: Kurzer Abgang, pflanzlich, Zitronenschalen, Salzlake …"
Caroni Kill Devil (The Whisky Barrel) HTR 1998
Caroni Kill Devil (The Whisky Barrel) HTR 1998Powerful, smoky industrial Caroni hit
"Normally, I am a big fan of Caroni, but this is one that is just okay. This is just an all-out assault of those aggressive industrial notes. Plenty of that roadside construction site going on without …"
Already featured? Enrich your blog
Use the free RumX widget to show community ratings on your own rum reviews. Drop-in code, no API key needed.