Foursquare Wagemut PX-Cask
Wagemut
Foursquare Wagemut PX-Cask8.0/10 (465 reviews)
Sherry · Raisin · Vanilla
Best Rums for Rum & Coke
A rum and coke is only as good as the rum: you want a versatile gold or aged rum with enough character to cut through cola, but easy on the wallet. The best rum & coke bottles you can buy now.
Rums in this list
Best for: Beginners and anyone who likes sweet, sherry-heavy sippers without added sugar
Loved as a sweet, sherry-driven daily sipper and a great first "real" rum. Beginners adore it; more experienced drinkers find it thin and one-note, and some say it's too sweet.
Planteray Extra Old XO 20th Anniversary
PlanterayPlanteray Extra Old XO 20th Anniversary8.0/10 (1,596 reviews)Vanilla · Caramel · CoconutBest for: beginners and fans of sweet, coconut-forward rum
The go-to first bottle for most members here — smooth, sweet and hard to fault. The common caveat: once your palate develops, the sugar and short finish start to show.
Hampden Pure Single Jamaican Rum
Hampden EstateHampden Pure Single Jamaican Rum8.0/10 (684 reviews)Ester · Banana · Tropical fruitsBest for: newcomers wanting a first taste of funky, fruity Jamaican rum
The go-to gateway into Hampden: friendly, fruity and well-balanced at 46%. Seasoned funk chasers find it tamer and drier than the overproof, but almost nobody regrets owning it.
Hampden Pure Single Jamaican Rum 8 Years Old OWH
Hampden EstateHampden Pure Single Jamaican Rum 8 Years Old OWH8.0/10 (259 reviews)Banana · Ester · Tropical fruitsBest for: newcomers wanting a first funky, fruity Jamaican rum
The go-to entry Hampden: fruity, approachable, fairly dry, with just enough funk to hint at the style. A few wish it had more ester punch and more proof.
Velier Hampden The Younger LROK 2016
HampdenVelier Hampden The Younger LROK 20168.0/10 (318 reviews)Ester · Pineapple · BananaBest for: Newcomers to Jamaican ester funk
Widely liked as an easy, affordable entry to Hampden funk. Full of pineapple, banana and esters, though many note it drinks a bit thin with a shortish finish for the mark.
Appleton Rare Casks 12 Years
Appleton EstateAppleton Rare Casks 12 Years7.6/10 (341 reviews)Vanilla · Oak · CaramelBest for: people easing into Jamaican rum who want it rounded, not wild
Most call it a rounded, well-made entry into Jamaican rum with great value; a minority finds it too woody, too diluted at 43%, and short on the funk they want.
Worthy Park Single Estate Reserve
Worthy ParkWorthy Park Single Estate Reserve7.8/10 (300 reviews)Banana · Tropical fruits · EsterBest for: newcomers wanting a fruity, lightly funky first Jamaican
Widely seen as the easy-entry Worthy Park — fruity, balanced, fairly priced. A vocal minority wants more funk, more body, or finds it thin and a touch hot.
Foursquare Doorly's 12 Years
Doorly'sFoursquare Doorly's 12 Years7.8/10 (336 reviews)Vanilla · Caramel · SpicyBest for: Fans of classic, unsweetened Barbados rum and newcomers
Widely loved as an honest, well-aged daily sipper at a fair price. The recurring gripe: 40% and the oak can leave keen drinkers wanting more punch and freshness.
Dos Maderas 5 Years + 5 Years PX
Dos MaderasDos Maderas 5 Years + 5 Years PX7.4/10 (581 reviews)Raisin · Sherry · CaramelBest for: People who like sweet, sherry-forward sippers and dessert rums
Loved as an easy, sweet sherry-forward sipper and a common beginner favorite. The recurring gripe: too sweet, the rum itself gets buried, and the 40% can feel a touch sharp.
Eminente Reserva 7 ans
EminenteEminente Reserva 7 ans7.5/10 (387 reviews)Caramel · Vanilla · ChocolateBest for: People easing into Cuban, Spanish-style sippers
Well-liked as a gentle, everyday Cuban sipper full of vanilla, caramel and coffee. The common gripes: short finish, a bit thin, and not much complexity for seasoned palates.
Elixir Distillers of London Black Tot Rum
Black Tot RumElixir Distillers of London Black Tot Rum7.5/10 (434 reviews)Caramel · Tropical fruits · Dark chocolateBest for: People wanting an affordable first step into navy-style rum
Most call it a well-balanced, easy navy sipper with great value. The honest catch: it can read thin, one-dimensional and a little hot, and the Jamaican notes come and go.
Foursquare Doorly's XO Fine Old Barbados Rum
Doorly'sFoursquare Doorly's XO Fine Old Barbados Rum7.5/10 (313 reviews)Vanilla · Caramel · SpiceBest for: beginners and bourbon drinkers easing into Barbados rum
Most land on the same verdict: a well-made, fairly priced everyday Barbados and a fine first Foursquare — just light and short, with a critical few calling it too thin and wood-dominated.
Price alerts, your collection and ratings in the RumX app
Free on iOS and Android.