Nobilis Montebello No. 22A (Brut de Colonne) 2019

These rums deliver far more quality than their price suggests, hand-picked for the best community score per euro.

Best for: Overproof and unaged agricole lovers chasing intensity
A brute-strength white agricole with melon, cane and floral notes, and shockingly well-integrated alcohol. Fans call it a fantastic surprise; non-agricole drinkers stay firmly out.

Best for: fans of wild, funky, grassy overproof rums and great daiquiris
The clear favourite among white-rum fans here — wild, smoky and intensely vegetal, with the heat better integrated than 69% should allow. Neat it's a lot; many reach for a daiquiri.

Best for: Fans of Demerara depth who also like Jamaican funk
A well-built Demerara-forward blend most tasters rate highly for its dark, roasted-fruity character and value. The main catch: the alcohol runs hot and a few water it down.

Best for: fans of loud, fruity, funky white rum and daiquiri lovers
Most tasters rate it high — a loud, fruit-and-ester white rum they call fun to drink, superb in a daiquiri. A few find it too chemical and artificial.

Best for: fans of loud, funky Jamaican rum and Mai Tai makers
A member favourite that keeps getting rebought: quintessential Jamaican funk at a fair price. The youth shows as a spiky, hot edge, but almost nobody holds it against the bottle.

Best for: fans of bright, fruity rum who want real strength behind it
Owners keep landing in the same place: a vivid, fruit-forward Australian with remarkably well-integrated alcohol for the proof. If you want a long finish, this one runs a bit short.

Best for: Hampden fans curious about a sherry twist
People land all over this one. The sherry-Hampden marriage wins most tasters over with cherry and spice, but several call it young, dry and too cask-driven to top a plain Hampden.

Best for: Agricole fans who want raw cane at full power
Loved as one of the best unaged agricoles around — intensely fresh cane, citrus and green notes with the 70% remarkably tamed. The catch: heat and heavy vegetal character aren't for everyone.

Best for: fans of fruity cask-finish rums who sip neat
Widely loved and a repeat bottle-killer here — the Armagnac finish adds fruit and depth without dominating. A couple of tasters find the menthol or thin mouthfeel not their thing.

Best for: Fans of cask-strength Belize and chocolate-coconut profiles
Well-liked Belize with big coconut-chocolate-caramel flavor and a Bounty-bar vibe. The recurring catch: the high ABV isn't always cleanly integrated, and it turns a touch bitter for some.
Free on iOS and Android.