Planteray Extra Old XO 20th Anniversary
Planteray
Planteray Extra Old XO 20th Anniversary8.0/10 (1,613 reviews)
Vanilla · Caramel · Coconut
Discover Barbados
Barbados is rum's elegant heart: balanced blends from Foursquare, Mount Gay and West Indies that please beginners and collectors alike.
Rums in this list
Best for: beginners and fans of sweet, coconut-forward rum
The go-to first bottle for most members here — smooth, sweet and hard to fault. The common caveat: once your palate develops, the sugar and short finish start to show.
Bumbu The Original
BumbuBumbu The Original7.0/10 (1,063 reviews)Banana · Vanilla · CaramelBest for: People who like sweet, soft, banana-forward sippers and rum newcomers
Loved by beginners, dismissed by veterans. Massive banana-vanilla-caramel sweetness that many find artificial and cloying; best over ice or in a sweet cocktail rather than analyzed neat.
Foursquare Doorly's 14 Years
Doorly'sFoursquare Doorly's 14 Years8.1/10 (470 reviews)Vanilla · Caramel · CoconutBest for: fans of dry, oaky Barbados rum wanting an everyday pour
The go-to everyday Bajan sipper here — drinkers agree it's the pick of the Doorly's range and a lot of rum for the money. A hair short on complexity and finish versus the ECS releases.
Mount Gay XO - Triple Cask Blend
Mount GayMount Gay XO - Triple Cask Blend7.8/10 (461 reviews)Vanilla · Caramel · OakBest for: Whisky and bourbon drinkers exploring classic Barbados rum
Well-liked as a smooth, balanced everyday Barbados rum with coconut-vanilla warmth. The common gripe: pleasant but not very complex, and the finish runs short for the age on the label.
Foursquare Wagemut PX-Cask
WagemutFoursquare Wagemut PX-Cask8.0/10 (487 reviews)Sherry · Raisin · VanillaBest for: Beginners and anyone who likes sweet, sherry-heavy sippers without added sugar
Loved as a sweet, sherry-driven daily sipper and a great first "real" rum. Beginners adore it; more experienced drinkers find it thin and one-note, and some say it's too sweet.
West Indies Rum Artesanal Barbados Rum Rockley Style BBR 1986
Rum ArtesanalWest Indies Rum Artesanal Barbados Rum Rockley Style BBR 19869.3/10 (97 reviews)Honey · Smoky · BarrelBest for: seasoned drinkers chasing complex, honeyed, lightly smoky old rum
A near-unanimous favourite — intensely complex, beautifully balanced, honey-soaked, with the alcohol so well integrated almost nobody notices the proof. A couple find the smoke or sweetness just isn't their thing.
Velier Foursquare Triptych
FoursquareVelier Foursquare Triptych8.9/10 (124 reviews)Coconut · Vanilla · CaramelBest for: Foursquare fans who like heavy oak
A very good Foursquare that most owners rate highly — balanced, warm, chocolate-and-oak driven. Several wish the virgin oak backed off, and a few find it woody to a fault.
Velier Foursquare Absolutio 2009
FoursquareVelier Foursquare Absolutio 20098.9/10 (259 reviews)Port · Vanilla · ChocolateBest for: Foursquare fans who like a port-driven, dried-fruit twist
Widely rated one of the best Velier Foursquares, loved for its port-driven dried fruit, chocolate and silky integration of a big ABV. Detractors call it too sweet or say the port dominates.
Velier Foursquare Plenipotenziario 2007
FoursquareVelier Foursquare Plenipotenziario 20078.8/10 (250 reviews)Vanilla · Coconut · Tropical fruitsBest for: Foursquare fans wanting a fruity, strong, dry Barbados rum
A clear favourite among Foursquare fans — the fruit, oak and cask strength all land in balance, and most rank it at the top of the Velier range. If you want something that breaks the Foursquare mould, this stays on profile.
Price alerts, your collection and ratings in the RumX app
Free on iOS and Android.