310,000+ honest rum ratings Europe’s largest rum selection: 6,400+ rums RumX app: 4.9 out of 5 on the App Store

310,000+ honest rum ratings

They come from members of the RumX app, not from us or the shops. Moderators, community reports and automated checks keep them clean. The score is the median.

How the score is made ›

Europe’s largest rum selection: 6,400+ rums

From 40+ specialist shops in one place, all ready to order right here. When several shops carry the same rum, we sort by total price including shipping to your country.

How we rank ›

RumX app: 4.9 out of 5 on the App Store

On Google Play 4.7 out of 5. In the app you rate rums yourself, and from your fifth rating on the Match Score shows which rums suit you.

Get the RumX app ›

Neat or in a cocktail? Both!

These all-rounder rums are the ideal ingredients for high-quality drinks or simply for a relaxed neat enjoyment.

Curated by crazyforgoodbooze
2,727 tastings
Updated June 2026

Philipp is a rum enthusiast and independent taster. He works at Perola GmbH; some reviewed bottlings may have a professional connection, but all reviews reflect his personal, unpaid opinion.

Rums in this list

  1. Best for: uniqueness chasers and peated-whisky, mezcal fans

    Praised as one of the most singular clairins around — smoky, meaty, olive-brined and perfumed. Most rate it high, but plenty admit the cheese-and-bacon nose isn't an everyday pour.

  2. CDI Jamaica Navy Strength

    CDI Jamaica Navy Strength
    Multi Distilleries
    CDI Jamaica Navy Strength
    7.6/10 (143 reviews)
    Jamaica · 5 years · 57%
    Banana · Tropical fruits · Ester
    70.70 €
    incl. shipping · 79.57 € per litre
    Add to cart

    Best for: People taking their first steps into overproof Jamaican funk

    A well-liked, affordable entry Jamaican — banana, funk and mild heat for 57%. Newcomers love it; seasoned funk fans say the alcohol reads sharp and there are bolder options.

  3. CDI West Indies - Old Blended Rum

    CDI West Indies - Old Blended Rum
    Compagnie des Indes
    CDI West Indies - Old Blended Rum
    7.5/10 (53 reviews)
    Multiple countries · 8 years · 40%
    Caramelized · Vanilla · Barrel
    34.52 €
    incl. shipping · 35.10 € per litre
    Add to cart

    Best for: People easing from sweet Spanish-style rums toward drier blends

    Most people find it smooth, balanced and dry-leaning, with a surprisingly good nose. The recurring gripe: at 40% it can feel thin and a touch flat for anyone wanting more punch.

  4. Best for: People wanting an easy way into Jamaican funk alongside soft Barbados sweetness

    A well-liked Barbados-Jamaica blend: coconut and vanilla meeting light banana funk. Most love the value and mix; some find the 50% a bit rough and edgy poured neat.

  5. Best for: Fans of high-ester funk and white-rum daiquiris

    A loved white ester blend: funky, fruity, and famously good value. Most call it a killer mixer that also holds up neat; a few find it too metallic or Savanna-heavy.

  6. Best for: People who love banana and sweeter, dessert-style rums

    Loved by banana fans as an easy after-dinner sipper, though several find it too sweet and one-dimensional. Genuine, natural banana flavor — but polarizing among rum purists.

  7. Best for: ester chasers who love savoury, funky rum

    A love-it-with-caveats crowd: most call it wildly flavorful and great in a daiquiri, though the raw-meat, plastic-ester side isn't for everyone. It rewards air time.

  8. Best for: Foursquare fans who want cask-strength Barbados without the ECS price

    Most drinkers love the chocolate-caramel-coconut profile and the power for the money. A few find the alcohol dominant or the palate a bit one-dimensional next to the ECS bottlings.

  9. Best for: Agricole fans and Ti' Punch / daiquiri makers

    Most agree it's a fresh, floral cane-juice white that shines in a Ti' Punch or daiquiri. A few find the palate a touch thin or the alcohol not fully tucked in.

  10. Best for: People who like soft, fruity, easy sippers and mixers

    Well-liked as an easy, fruity everyday Belize and a strong mixer at this strength. The catch: the nose can read thin and there's little "special" for experienced drinkers.

  11. Don Q Double Cask Vermouth Finish

    Don Q Double Cask Vermouth Finish
    Don Q
    Don Q Double Cask Vermouth Finish
    7.0/10 (30 reviews)
    Puerto Rico · 1mo - 8 years · 40%
    Wine · Caramel · Dates
    48.65 €
    incl. shipping · 59.51 € per litre
    Add to cart

    Best for: People curious about vermouth cask finishes and cocktail experiments

    Divisive. Most agree the vermouth dominates and the rum sits in the passenger seat — some find it fascinating, others dull or too herbal neat. A few swear by it in a rum Manhattan.

  12. Cihuatán Indigo

    Cihuatán Indigo
    Cihuatán
    Cihuatán Indigo
    7.1/10 (224 reviews)
    El Salvador · 8 years · 40%
    Vanilla · Milk chocolate · Hazelnut
    38.31 €
    incl. shipping · 46.30 € per litre
    Add to cart

    Best for: People who like sweet, chocolatey, easy sippers

    Widely liked as a sweet, chocolatey everyday sipper with great value. Most agree it's easy but simple, with a short finish; a few find it too sweet and one-note.

Price alerts, your collection and ratings in the RumX app

Free on iOS and Android.

Download on the App Store Get it on Google Play
★ 4.8/5 on App Store & Play Store