320,000+ honest rum ratings Europe’s largest rum selection: 6,500+ rums RumX app: 4.9 out of 5 on the App Store

320,000+ honest rum ratings

They come from members of the RumX app, not from us or the shops. Moderators, community reports and automated checks keep them clean. The score is the median.

How the score is made

Europe’s largest rum selection: 6,500+ rums

From 40+ specialist shops in one place, all ready to order right here. When several shops carry the same rum, we sort by total price including shipping to your country.

View all rums

RumX app: 4.9 out of 5 on the App Store

On Google Play 4.7 out of 5. In the app you rate rums yourself, and from your fifth rating on the Match Score shows which rums suit you.

Get the RumX app
9C75B87E-3989-46C8-9632-E3A52400C103Trinidad Caroni Schotman's Barrel Selection
Schotman's Barrel Selection Caroni 1999 70cl bottle
Bottle
View 2
Taste
Aged rum · 19 years · 61,2% · 70cl

Schotman's Barrel Selection Caroni 1999

Dirty, tar-heavy Caroni with a fruity streak

Less suitable for newcomers put off by medicinal, rubbery rum

Currently unavailable

Delivery to

Buying advice

These ship to you

Similar in style and available now.

Is it your taste?

How does Schotman's Barrel Selection Caroni 1999 taste?

Dirty, tar-heavy Caroni with a fruity streak

Tar, rubber and warm licorice up front, with more fresh fruit than most Caronis — cherry, mango, dried apricot cutting through the dirt. Several tasters call this their dirtiest Caroni yet, but a fruity streak and well-integrated alcohol keep it from turning into a chore at 61%. Definitely not an everyday pour, but the people here who chase the tar-and-plastic side of Trinidad love this one.

Style & occasion: Mature & oakySipping neat

From community reviews · summarized with AI

Perfect for

Caroni fans who chase tar and dirt

Less suitable for

newcomers put off by medicinal, rubbery rum

Frequently mentioned aromas

Mostly Funk, with Wood & roast.

On the palate
Rubber Fruity Tar Roasted

From 24 detailed tastings

The aroma profile in detail Nose and palate from 24 detailed tastings
Number in the dot: share in percent
AromaOn the noseOn the palateOn the finish
Funk
Tar67 %54 %not mentioned
Rubber58 %63 %not mentioned
Solvents42 %not mentionednot mentioned
Bicycle tube38 %not mentionednot mentioned
Wood & roast
Roasted33 %50 %not mentioned
Woodynot mentioned42 %42 %
Burntnot mentioned42 %not mentioned
Leather42 %not mentionednot mentioned
Barrelnot mentionednot mentioned33 %
Spice
Licoricenot mentioned38 %46 %
Fruit
Fruity54 %58 %not mentioned
Other
Bitternot mentionednot mentioned25 %

Also mentioned: Iodine 25 %, Black tea 21 %, Mocha 21 %

Finish: long, in 13 of 18 entries.

What does the community say?

8.6/10 Very good

35 community reviews

Rating scale & review checks

On RumX, 7 means “Good” and 8 means “Very good”. See the full rating guide

  • From members, not from shops.
  • One vote per member; the score is the median.
  • Checked automatically and by moderators.
How ratings are made and how we check them
Rating distribution

What members praise Classic tar and rubber · Fruity for a Caroni · Alcohol well integrated

What bothers them Heavy for some · Bitter finish · Not an everyday pour

Summarised from the tasting notes

The most helpful voices

The review with the most helpful votes in each rating group. The distribution above shows how often each score was given.

Positive voice

Lukas Jägerhas rated 545 rums · Germany

9.0/10

RumX Advent calendar, 11.12.2021, blind. Definitely Caroni and a very dirty representative. Blind then even settled on this bottling, I think it's great. Original review: Tasted for the first time at the 10th GRF in Berlin with René van Houven, thank you very much! A great Caroni that somehow inspires me. Certainly not as spectacular as other boards, especially from the well-known great vintages, this Caroni convinces me above all with its versatility. The subtle and rather fruity nose turns into wood, coffee and other bitter notes on the palate and less clearly, but definitely there is then also banished rubber and tar, so that it is also clear here: Caroni! Half a barrel and only 70 bottles, that's when the "want-to-have" instinct kicks in!

41 found this helpful · Jun 2024

All 21 positive reviews 

Mixed voice

MarcThas rated 226 rums · Germany

7.5/10

Now I get the "Caroni tastes dirty, like tar and plastic" comments, this one at least gives me the impression that this is what people mean, when saying that.

18 found this helpful · Jan 2022

22 selected written reviews

The distribution above includes all 35 ratings, including those without text.

Jakob

Jakob

1,673 reviewsSwitzerland
8.4/10

Very classic Caroni profile, positioned not only by vintage between the common 98 and 2000 profiles with distinct tar and rubber notes combined with menthol and a bit of caramel sweetness. A positive surprise, a really good bottling. As Steffen Mayer revealed in his Caroni bible, the same base product was bottled for Whisky Import First Cask, Schotman, and Wigman Caroni. Flavor-wise, this only partially holds true; the basic aroma is clearly related, but the expressions tend to go in quite different directions. Exciting and a bit confusing at the same time. In a direct comparison, the Schotman and Wigman bottlings clearly stand out for me over the First Cask, whose very astringent finish is its downfall.

Johannes

Johannes

3,272 reviewsGermany
8.4/10

Beautifully complex Caroni!

Galli33

Galli33

554 reviewsItaly
9.0/10

#11 RumXCalendar Blind tasting: N: Woody, dirty, tar, minty, licorice, Mango M: tar, licorice, minty, wood, bitter, dry, leather F: wood(oak), vanilla, dry, black tea Prediction: this is definitely a caroni, approx. 15+ year and 60%…. I got it! It‘s a very delicious caroni. If you like it dirty, you‘ll love this one! Alcohol is integrated very well. Nose: dirty, tar, rubber, fruity, leather, minty, licorice, maple, mango, roasted, tobacco Mouth: Dry, dirty, delicious, bitter, complex, intense, minty, licorice, smoky, roasted, fruity Finish: dry, oak, astrigend, salty, tar, woody, black tea, mocha, licorice

Frank

Frank

730 reviews
9.0/10

RumX Advent calendar, 11.12., blind, First impression: this is a Caroni! And at 60%. That's right and I know it. I already found it good with René's rarities. This is now confirmed once again. Nose: intense and complex, yet round. First of all, typical Caroni tar and iodine with singed plastic but at the same time with a sweet caramel note and a certain fruitiness, like cherry with dried, sulphurized apricot. Dry tobacco with vanilla and a very light vinegar note at the back. Palate: full-bodied, intense and really tasty. Initially, phenol and iodine predominate with light mint, slightly salted and toasted. Then fruity redcurrant and lime. At the back again rubber and bodily violet and some black tea. Surprisingly good!!!

Thunderbird

Thunderbird

1,401 reviewsGermany
8.6/10

This is the dirtiest Caroni I've tasted so far... like chewing on a licorice root! Too strong for me

DomM

DomM

1,057 reviewsGermany
8.8/10

Rather on the dirty side. Surprisingly good Caroni imo.

Tschusikowsky

Tschusikowsky

571 reviewsSwitzerland
8.7/10

RumX Advent calendar 11.12.21: Awesome Caroni. The essence of the profile totally in there. Nothing for every day, but accessible and complex at the same time. My dirtiest Caroni yet. Awesome advent calendar!

SaibotZtar

SaibotZtar

623 reviewsGermany
8.7/10

RumX Advent calendar 2021 Day 11 Great Caroni... has nice fruit and is not too dirty... Finish a little bitter but within reason. I like it .

mto75

mto75

742 reviewsGermany
8.9/10

Perhaps it lacks a little of the depth of the '96 Veliers, but for me it is an extremely well-balanced Caroni!

Kevin Sorensen 🇩🇰

Kevin Sorensen 🇩🇰

7,408 reviewsDenmark
8.7/10

15.07.2021 Nothing better than meeting people for dinner and rum when you're on holiday. Notes Dark to very dark in colour. Nose Wood, light smoke, light tar, rubber, faint leather, anise. Palate Wood, roasted, cherry, raisin, light tar, rubber, medicinal, light licorice. Finish Long, wood, roasted, raisin, cherry, medium dry, anise.

Rowald Sweet Empire

Rowald Sweet Empire

431 reviewsNetherlands
8.9/10

Typical tar and fermented berries in the nose. But also something herbal/cough syrop/fresh/menthol in the nose. More licorise/bay leaf in taste than in smell. Less fruity. Thick syropy stuff. Weird but tasty and interesting. An a-typical Caroni.

tojo

tojo

110 reviewsGermany
8.7/10

Has everything a good Caroni needs!

Stylo

Stylo

102 reviews
8.4/10

Light brown with almost green hue on the edges. Nose: Weird! I immediately get notes of medicines, fully integrated with fresh menthol, intertwined with a dusty sensation, almost like you’re taking a big sniff at your old grandma’s medicine cabinet. In background, I feel that there’s a hidden, sweeter note. Mouth: well..it must be Trinidad..in its full tar, medicine, dust, menthol, dirty glory..here the sweeter note I sensed while sniffing it, reveal itself clearly as licorice.. you also get that warm, astringent feel as other Caroni I’ve tasted.

Pavel Spacek

Pavel Spacek

1,901 reviewsCzech
8.4/10

... Caroni is a distillery from Trinidad that produced rum at the height of its glory, which was added in a ratio of 1:10 to the naval blend. It was too strong and strange to be pleasant on the tongue. The distillery ceased production and closed in 2000. Only in 2010 did tasters appear who liked the rum precisely for its special taste. And interest grew. Caroni belongs to the category of rums "you need to try before you die." I recommend it, Caroni is truly a unique rum.

Rene Pfeiffer

Rene Pfeiffer

264 reviewsGermany
8.6/10

Day 11 RumX Advent calendar: Nose: dirty, bicycle inner tube, fruity, medicinal. Strange but interesting blend that I haven't had before. Alcohol very well integrated. Palate: Intense, heavy, dry, medicinal, burnt, licorice and tea. No idea what that is... Lots of different flavors, interesting, but absolutely not for every day. The resolution said Caroni 1999, aye. That explains why I had zero plan, because it was only the 2nd Caroni.

Michael Schillheim

Michael Schillheim

161 reviews
9.0/10

After the disappointing '96 CDI, this is now my second Caroni. I find the dirty notes spectacular both on the nose and on the palate. A really great rum.

Pascal Elkuch

16 reviewsSwitzerland
9.0/10

Awesome thing.

Christoph

Christoph

454 reviewsGermany
8.6/10

Typical dirty Caroni profile on the nose and in the mouth with relatively much fruit. It runs out of dirt in the finish, which is replaced by black tea and salty bacon.

Christian Rudt

Christian Rudt

588 reviewsGermany
8.7/10

Compared to yesterday's Bristol Caroni, it's a little rounder and more pleasing with a nice fruity impact.

Pavel Ungr, RumRock

Pavel Ungr, RumRock

1,562 reviewsCzech
8.2/10

Vintage 1999. I rate it 8.2 out of 10, very good rum.

Lukas Jäger

545 reviewsGermany
9.0/10

RumX Advent calendar, 11.12.2021, blind. Definitely Caroni and a very dirty representative. Blind then even settled on this bottling, I think it's great. Original review: Tasted for the first time at the 10th GRF in Berlin with René van Houven, thank you very much! A great Caroni that somehow inspires me. Certainly not as spectacular as other boards, especially from the well-known great vintages, this Caroni convinces me above all with its versatility. The subtle and rather fruity nose turns into wood, coffee and other bitter notes on the palate and less clearly, but definitely there is then also banished rubber and tar, so that it is also clear here: Caroni! Half a barrel and only 70 bottles, that's when the "want-to-have" instinct kicks in!

MarcT

226 reviewsGermany
7.5/10

Now I get the "Caroni tastes dirty, like tar and plastic" comments, this one at least gives me the impression that this is what people mean, when saying that.

Tried it already?

Rate this rum in the RumX app and help others choose.

Rate it in the app

Community shelf

15 of 20 bottles are still sealed.

  • 15 sealed
  • 2 open
  • 3 emptied
  • 20 bottles on the shelf, owned by 13 members
  • 35 tastings
  • 9 wishlists

Members paid a median of 262 €.

The middle 80% of purchase prices were between 260 and 328 €.

17 purchases by 10 members since August 2021. Self-reported and unverified, not a shop price.

Price history with 2 auctions in RX+

Reported by RumX members from their collections · as of How these numbers are made

Details about Schotman's Barrel Selection Caroni 1999

A rum from Trinidad, bottled by Schotman's Barrel Selection, at 61,2%.

Origin

DistilleryCaroniover 620 rums on RumX · avg 8.8/10 from 10,906 ratings
CountryTrinidad

Production

Raw materialMolasses
Age19 years
Vintage1999

In the bottle

ABV61,2%
Volume70cl
Limited edition70 bottles

Read on in the RumX Guide

You may also enjoy

Members who rate this rum highly often rate these highly too.

Discover more alternatives

Shopping safely on RumX

Your retailer delivers. We are here to help.

The retailer named in the offer is your seller and ships your bottle. You order and pay here on RumX. Our team helps you resolve questions with the shop.

Help with your order
Oliver, founder of RumX

Oliver GerhardtFounder of RumX, Stuttgart

“I started RumX in 2018 as a rum fan and I still build it myself today. If something is wrong with your order, write to us. No call centre will answer, but my small team or me.”
As featured in
Stern Stuttgarter Zeitung Rumporter fizzz About Drinks
All press coverage

Any questions before you buy?

Who sells and ships the bottle?

The retailer named in the offer is your seller and ships your bottle. You order and pay here on RumX. Our team helps you resolve questions with the shop. Help with your order

Is shipping included in the price?

When shipping costs for your destination are known, we show the total and break out the bottle price and shipping. Change the delivery country in the offer to see the applicable price. View offer

Can I return the bottle?

Your purchase contract is with the shop, so returns and cancellations run through them under their own policy and your statutory rights. If anything goes wrong, RumX helps you sort it out.

Are the reviews from buyers?

Reviews are from RumX community members. A purchase through RumX is not required. The overall score is the median of the ratings. Rating scale & review checks

Price alerts · in the RumX app
Never miss a price drop.

Set a target price in the app, and we'll let you know as soon as the rum becomes available at that price from one of our partner stores. This works for any rum on your wish list.

★ 4.8/5 on App Store & Play Store
Rating guide

Every score is the median of members’ ratings, from 0 to 10. A 7 is already a recommendation to buy.

Share of 11,355 rums with at least 4 ratings, calculated on November 20, 2026. Scale and calculation in detail