320,000+ honest rum ratings Europe’s largest rum selection: 6,500+ rums RumX app: 4.9 out of 5 on the App Store

320,000+ honest rum ratings

They come from members of the RumX app, not from us or the shops. Moderators, community reports and automated checks keep them clean. The score is the median.

How the score is made

Europe’s largest rum selection: 6,500+ rums

From 40+ specialist shops in one place, all ready to order right here. When several shops carry the same rum, we sort by total price including shipping to your country.

View all rums

RumX app: 4.9 out of 5 on the App Store

On Google Play 4.7 out of 5. In the app you rate rums yourself, and from your fifth rating on the Match Score shows which rums suit you.

Get the RumX app
1e7af920-284a-11ed-a169-e1b428060350Barbados Foursquare Schotman's Barrel Selection
Schotman's Barrel Selection Foursquare Barbados Rum 17 2005 70cl bottle
Bottle
View 2
Taste
Aged rum · 17 years · 58,4% · 70cl

Schotman's Barrel Selection Foursquare Barbados Rum 17 2005

Rounded, coconut-forward cask-strength Foursquare

Less suitable for anyone after spicy, deep, wood-driven FS

Buying advice

These ship to you

Similar in style and available now.

Is it your taste?

How does Schotman's Barrel Selection Foursquare Barbados Rum 17 2005 taste?

Rounded, coconut-forward cask-strength Foursquare

Sipped neat at cask strength, this is a fruity, coconut-forward Foursquare — coconut milk, banana and orange up front, with light oak and vanilla underneath. Most drinkers find the alcohol well integrated for 58.4%, though a few notice a metallic, bitter-sour edge on the palate. Rounder and softer than the spicier Foursquares, with less of their usual pepper punch.

Style & occasion: Mature & oakySipping neat

From community reviews · summarized with AI

Perfect for

Foursquare fans who like coconut and fruit

Less suitable for

anyone after spicy, deep, wood-driven FS

Frequently mentioned aromas

On the palate
Coconut Oak Orange Caramel
On the finish
Coconut Caramel Oak Vanilla

From 20 detailed tastings

The aroma profile in detail Nose and palate from 20 detailed tastings
Number in the dot: share in percent
AromaOn the noseOn the palateOn the finish
Wood & roast
Oak45 %65 %35 %
Milk chocolate45 %40 %25 %
Roasted45 %not mentionednot mentioned
Tropical
Coconut90 %95 %55 %
Banana55 %not mentionednot mentioned
Spice
Vanilla65 %45 %35 %
Spicynot mentioned35 %35 %
Saltynot mentioned35 %not mentioned
Fruit
Orangenot mentioned60 %25 %
Fruity35 %not mentionednot mentioned
Sweet
Caramel55 %50 %45 %
Funk
Metallicnot mentionednot mentioned25 %

Finish: medium, in 9 of 12 entries.

What does the community say?

8.2/10 Very good

51 community reviews

Rating scale & review checks

On RumX, 7 means “Good” and 8 means “Very good”. See the full rating guide

  • From members, not from shops.
  • One vote per member; the score is the median.
  • Checked automatically and by moderators.
How ratings are made and how we check them
Rating distribution

What members praise Coconut & orange · Well-integrated proof · Balanced & round

What bothers them Metallic edge · Softer than usual FS · Coconut-heavy

Summarised from the tasting notes

The most helpful voices

The review with the most helpful votes in each rating group. The distribution above shows how often each score was given.

Positive voice

cigares has rated 1,183 rums · Switzerland

8.0/10

Un nez de vernis et d’acétone, des fruits, des pâtisseries mais en arrière plan, banane et acérola. L’entrée de bouche est creuse, heurtée et chaotique. Le vernis/acétone domine. Après de longues secondes les fruits prennent le relais et forment une finale avec sucre brun, banane et acérola correcte. La finale, amère, mais plus équilibrée sauve ce rhum. Un des moins bon Foursquare que j’ai eu dans mon verre. Bien meilleur pourtant qu’à ma première dégustation.

42 found this helpful · Jul 2025

All 23 positive reviews 

Mixed voice

Gunnar Böhme "Bauerngaumen" 🤓has rated 725 rums · Germany

7.8/10

Nice daily sipper, but doesn't sweep me off my feet. This rum also does not make me a Foursquare friend, it has nothing that makes me pay attention. For my taste also too expensive.

23 found this helpful · Nov 2022

All 5 mixed reviews 

28 selected written reviews

The distribution above includes all 51 ratings, including those without text.

Lukas Jäger

545 reviewsGermany
8.7/10

Tried at the 11th GRF and perhaps the secret highlight. Tasty Foursquare with character at a reasonable and fair price. No finish or barrel experiments, plus a nice and sympathetic team behind it, has me excited!

Kevin Sorensen 🇩🇰

Kevin Sorensen 🇩🇰

7,408 reviewsDenmark
8.5/10

03.06.2026 Retasting and I still think it is pretty good. ----- 02.03.2023 Enjoying some samples at home. Colour Medium dark in colour. Nose Round, balanced, wood, light roasted, fruity, light banana, faint coconut, faint caramel, spice. Palate Round, wood, light roasted, fruits, light orange, faint chocolate, nutmeg, light coconut, light banana, spice. Finish Medium to long, wood, light roasted, light banana, light orange, spice, light caramel, faint chocolate.

Jakob

Jakob

1,673 reviewsSwitzerland
8.5/10

Very pleasantly round and sweet. Almost an easy sipper. The strong spicy notes of other Foursquares are largely absent from this release - blind I would probably have been more with Belize. But of course the profile remains typical for Foursquare. Great release.

Frank

Frank

730 reviews
8.0/10

Oh wow, super intense tropical coconut aromas on the nose. More precisely, fine coconut milk. In addition, very light and in the background banana and orange. Slowly comes a little vanilla and the wood takes over, but very subtle and rather fragrant cherry wood. I also detect a very subtle note of marzipan. Smells good. Palate: equally fruity-spicy, with coconut and orange, but first comes a tart, dry, almost metallic and slightly bitter-sour-salty thrust, which then turns into lime zest with animal currant and some oak. Then at the back again coconut with orange and still slightly metallic. Am not a ⏹️ fan, but this one is not bad.

Leo Krüper

Leo Krüper

983 reviewsGermany
8.3/10

Nice, smooth Foursquare. Has everything you expect in a pleasant drinking strength.

crazyforgoodbooze

crazyforgoodbooze

2,676 reviewsGermany
7.5/10

Halfway tasty old foursquare but there are the "sister barrels" isonomy and royal Cane in my opinion much more harmonious and milder. This one is just too metallic and sharp for me...

Johannes

Johannes

3,272 reviewsGermany
8.1/10

Amazingly good Foursquare!

Timo Groeger

Timo Groeger

3,408 reviewsGermany
8.2/10

Whisky Fair Rhein-Ruhr Düsseldorf April 2026. Schotmans Barrel Selection Foursquare Barbados Rum 17 2005. Jedenfalls wieder so ein fruchtiges Teil mit viel Kokosnuss, etwas Vanille und Karamell, aber da gibt es echt schlechtere.

Christoph

Christoph

454 reviewsGermany
8.8/10

Tasted quickly without expectations and had one of the best FS I know in the glass.

DomM

DomM

1,057 reviewsGermany
8.2/10

Well rounded and wood forward FS.

Piotr Ignasiak

Piotr Ignasiak

245 reviewsPoland
7.9/10

Smells great, I get a typical pleasant Foursquare profile then with coconut, vanilla, coffee, some spices. On the palate a lot of coffee, red fruit and also this bitter sour and then metallic salty note in the background that I can't really call. Overall quite fine though I prefer the ECS releases that I have tried before, also that one note on the palate was a bit disturbing.

Sebastian Kornett
9.3/10

An extraordinary Foursquare that is ranked very high. Very balanced and complex.

Christian Rudt

Christian Rudt

588 reviewsGermany
8.6/10

Have now tasted this rum at the second German Rumfestival in a row. And what can I say. I just like it. Class barrel selection. Not overlaid. Successful bottling. Am glad here again a larger sample at the bottler to have grabbed. This Foursquare is fun.☺️😋

Andi

Andi

272 reviews
8.5/10

Wow, very fruity, coconut, banana, in addition pairs vanilla, caramel and chocolate. For me personally the best Barbados rum I have tasted so far.

Master P

Master P

367 reviewsGermany
8.1/10

After pouring into the glass, I first perceive coconut and some vanilla. The taste is very thin and sweet, coconut naturally and very slight orange. The finish is then very sharp-edged and slightly spicy. You can sip it, but the price-performance ratio is rather poor. Sample is enough here.

Richard Krupa

Richard Krupa

882 reviewsCzech
7.5/10

caramel, softer. Light tail at the end

Agricoler

Agricoler

234 reviewsGermany
8.4/10

Good Foursquare. My comparison of the Nobillary. This one seems even more concentrated. What is very pleasant, however, is the orange note. This is rarely found in the nose alongside the light floral notes. A very successful bottling with perfectly integrated alcohol.

Michael Schillheim

Michael Schillheim

161 reviews
8.8/10

Tasted at the 11th GRF. A surprise of the festival for me. Very good tum from the house of Foursquare.

Jarek

Jarek

786 reviewsGermany
8.3/10

Eigentlich ganz gut, aber der Alkohol ist ein kleines Bisschen zu dominant. Nachverkostung am kleinen Foursquare-Abend. Inzwischen etwas länger offen und vielleicht mehr oxidiert. Hat dem Rum gut getan, im Bezug auf die Alkoholintegration.

Pavel Spacek

Pavel Spacek

1,901 reviewsCzech
8.1/10

... Foursquare is a distillery from Barbados producing amazing rums for everyday sipping. This is a rum especially appreciated by rum lovers who are fed up with sugar and looking for a gentle, sweet rum full of coconut, vanilla, chocolate and caramel. Simply pleasant and not aggressive flavors.

Anonymous

1 review
6.5/10

+ soft, smooth, warms the stone

Mentalo

627 reviewsGermany
8.2/10

One of the better Foursquare rums, but even here it lacks depth and if you're not the biggest coconut fan. Slight barrel note makes it a bit more interesting, but it's just not my profile.

Basti

Basti

563 reviewsGermany
8.5/10

Fair rating. On a par with most ECS bottlings. Unfortunately not as attractive in terms of price.

Michal Jurka

Michal Jurka

335 reviewsCzech
8.2/10

Winter RumFest Prague 2026

Sebastiaan Linssen

211 reviewsNetherlands
9.0/10

This an excellent rum. I have discovered this brand at Rum Depot. Pleasant surprise. I tasted the rum together with the 19. Fantastic balanced taste. I prefer the 17 over the 19, the alcohol seems better integrated.

Pavel Ungr, RumRock

Pavel Ungr, RumRock

1,562 reviewsCzech
8.1/10

Ročník 2005. S 8,1 z 10 jde o velmi dobrou lahev, byť ne špičku mého žebříčku.

cigares

cigares

1,183 reviewsSwitzerland
8.0/10

Un nez de vernis et d’acétone, des fruits, des pâtisseries mais en arrière plan, banane et acérola. L’entrée de bouche est creuse, heurtée et chaotique. Le vernis/acétone domine. Après de longues secondes les fruits prennent le relais et forment une finale avec sucre brun, banane et acérola correcte. La finale, amère, mais plus équilibrée sauve ce rhum. Un des moins bon Foursquare que j’ai eu dans mon verre. Bien meilleur pourtant qu’à ma première dégustation.

Gunnar Böhme "Bauerngaumen" 🤓
7.8/10

Nice daily sipper, but doesn't sweep me off my feet. This rum also does not make me a Foursquare friend, it has nothing that makes me pay attention. For my taste also too expensive.

Tried it already?

Rate this rum in the RumX app and help others choose.

Rate it in the app

Community shelf

10 of 12 bottles are still sealed.

  • 10 sealed
  • 0 open
  • 2 emptied
  • 12 bottles on the shelf, owned by 12 members
  • 52 tastings
  • 1 wishlist

Members paid a median of 150 €.

The middle 80% of purchase prices were between 129 and 165 €.

8 purchases by 8 members since August 2022. Self-reported and unverified, not a shop price.

Full price history in RX+

Reported by RumX members from their collections · as of How these numbers are made

Details about Schotman's Barrel Selection Foursquare Barbados Rum 17 2005

A rum from Barbados, bottled by Schotman's Barrel Selection, at 58,4%.

Origin

DistilleryFoursquareover 640 rums on RumX · avg 8.3/10 from 15,275 ratings
CountryBarbados

Production

Raw materialMolasses
Age17 years
Vintage2005

In the bottle

ABV58,4%
Volume70cl
Limited editionYes

Read on in the RumX Guide

You may also enjoy

Members who rate this rum highly often rate these highly too.

Discover more alternatives

Shopping safely on RumX

Your retailer delivers. We are here to help.

The retailer named in the offer is your seller and ships your bottle. You order and pay here on RumX. Our team helps you resolve questions with the shop.

Help with your order
Oliver, founder of RumX

Oliver GerhardtFounder of RumX, Stuttgart

“I started RumX in 2018 as a rum fan and I still build it myself today. If something is wrong with your order, write to us. No call centre will answer, but my small team or me.”
As featured in
Stern Stuttgarter Zeitung Rumporter fizzz About Drinks
All press coverage

Any questions before you buy?

Who sells and ships the bottle?

The retailer named in the offer is your seller and ships your bottle. You order and pay here on RumX. Our team helps you resolve questions with the shop. Help with your order

Is shipping included in the price?

When shipping costs for your destination are known, we show the total and break out the bottle price and shipping. Change the delivery country in the offer to see the applicable price. View offer

Can I return the bottle?

Your purchase contract is with the shop, so returns and cancellations run through them under their own policy and your statutory rights. If anything goes wrong, RumX helps you sort it out.

Are the reviews from buyers?

Reviews are from RumX community members. A purchase through RumX is not required. The overall score is the median of the ratings. Rating scale & review checks

Price alerts · in the RumX app
Never miss a price drop.

Set a target price in the app, and we'll let you know as soon as the rum becomes available at that price from one of our partner stores. This works for any rum on your wish list.

★ 4.8/5 on App Store & Play Store
Rating guide

Every score is the median of members’ ratings, from 0 to 10. A 7 is already a recommendation to buy.

Share of 11,355 rums with at least 4 ratings, calculated on November 20, 2026. Scale and calculation in detail