320,000+ honest rum ratings Europe’s largest rum selection: 6,500+ rums RumX app: 4.9 out of 5 on the App Store

320,000+ honest rum ratings

They come from members of the RumX app, not from us or the shops. Moderators, community reports and automated checks keep them clean. The score is the median.

How the score is made

Europe’s largest rum selection: 6,500+ rums

From 40+ specialist shops in one place, all ready to order right here. When several shops carry the same rum, we sort by total price including shipping to your country.

View all rums

RumX app: 4.9 out of 5 on the App Store

On Google Play 4.7 out of 5. In the app you rate rums yourself, and from your fifth rating on the Match Score shows which rums suit you.

Get the RumX app
ccc9cf20-270d-11ee-8dee-5f19d714df6dReunion Savanna Holmes Cay
Holmes Cay Savanna Réunion Island Grand Arôme Rum No. 3 2023 75cl bottle
Images
Bottle
Taste
Videos about this rum
The Rum Revival
The Rum Revival
White rum · 57,5% · 75cl

Holmes Cay Savanna Réunion Island Grand Arôme Rum No. 3 2023

Savory olive-brine funk, more curiosity than sipper

Less suitable for anyone wanting a sweet, easy sipper

Buying advice

These ship to you

Similar in style and available now.

Is it your taste?

How does Holmes Cay Savanna Réunion Island Grand Arôme Rum No. 3 2023 taste?

Savory olive-brine funk, more curiosity than sipper

Most tasters land on "wildly interesting" rather than easy — this is olive brine, nail polish remover and salty herbs from the first sniff, and it barely reads like rum. One reviewer calls it "a dirty martini in a bottle" with a lemon twist. Behind the acetone there's overripe tropical fruit, mint and a metallic, sour edge. At 57.5% it's loud, savory and completely singular.

Style & occasion: Fresh & grassySipping neatCocktails & mixing

From community reviews · summarized with AI

Perfect for

funk chasers who want the strange stuff

Less suitable for

anyone wanting a sweet, easy sipper

Frequently mentioned aromas

Mostly Funk, with Vegetal.

From 13 detailed tastings

The aroma profile in detail Nose and palate from 13 detailed tastings
Number in the dot: mentions in 13 detailed tastings
AromaOn the noseOn the palateOn the finish
Funk
Brine67not mentioned
Nail polish67not mentioned
Solvents7not mentionednot mentioned
Ester541
Medicinalnot mentionednot mentioned2
Vegetal
Olive89not mentioned
Vegetal462
Herbalnot mentioned63
Fruit
Fruitynot mentionednot mentioned4
Sour4not mentionednot mentioned
Berriesnot mentionednot mentioned2
Spice
Salty462

Also mentioned: Menthol 2

What does the community say?

7.9/10 Good

35 community reviews

Rating scale & review checks

On RumX, 7 means “Good” and 8 means “Very good”. See the full rating guide

  • From members, not from shops.
  • One vote per member; the score is the median.
  • Checked automatically and by moderators.
How ratings are made and how we check them
Rating distribution

What members praise Olive-brine funk · Loud and unique · Great in cocktails

What bothers them Very savory · Acetone-heavy nose · Not for everyone

Summarised from the tasting notes

The most helpful voices

The review with the most helpful votes in each rating group. The distribution above shows how often each score was given.

Positive voice

Kevin Sorensen 🇩🇰has rated 7,408 rums · Denmark

8.8/10

#5394 13.06.2025 Enjoying a few samples to the beats of Psy-Fi Festival 2025. Nose Fresh, medium intense, fruity, light berries, light citrus, sugarcane, faint plastic. Palate Fresh, medium intense, fruity, naturally sweet, light metallic, olive, light mint, faint salt, light mango, cherry, light floral. Finish Long and warm, fruity, light citrus, light anise, berries. Empty glass Citrus, light licorice, light manto, light strawberry, faint metallic.

20 found this helpful · Jun 2025

All 6 positive reviews 

Mixed voice

Beancheesehas rated 103 rums · Canada

7.0/10

What a wild ride this rum is. Right away the nose hit me with olive brine and nail polish remover, so much so that I almost couldn’t get past it. I could try to find other notes hiding behind there but it was just so overwhelmingly true to those two items that it felt like I was ‘trying’ to find something more. Both of these notes hold true and dominate on the palate as well, although this funky rum has a bit more going on. Behind the salty olive brine and acetone there was also permanent marker, a bit of something peaty or smoky, some mild licorice like spice. This was a wildly interesting way to sample my first rum from Reunion but I would never catch myself drinking this as a regular sipper. I think an imaginative mixer could make great use of this in a cocktail however and it is perfect for nerding out. I will score it 6.5 because it’s just not my palate if I was looking for something to enjoy sipping - but it’s so curious and fun that the ‘experience’ of trying it could be 8+

23 found this helpful · Jun 2024

All 5 mixed reviews 

Critical voice

RumCzarhas rated 42 rums · USA

5.0/10

This rum was a huge disappointment. I heard great things about the Grand Arome, and I thought it would compare favorably to Jamaica hogo, but the Grand Arome is way to savory for me. It's flavor reminds me of hot dogs and pickles and witch hazel. That's not a flavor I want from my rum. Sorry folks! I won't rebuy.

3 found this helpful · May 2024

All 2 critical reviews 

13 selected written reviews

The distribution above includes all 35 ratings, including those without text.

Martin Ekrt

Martin Ekrt

354 reviewsCzech
8.4/10

A very wild scent, I'd guess some Haitian Clairin. Olives at first, meaty saltiness, later downright herbal schnapps. Taste-wise, it's wild, too. Full of herbs and vegetable elements, saltiness. Very interesting stuff for lovers of weirdness.

abaker-rum

135 reviewsUSA
7.4/10

I was a bit surprised by this rum since it is my first molasses based rum that has all of the notes I expect from an agricole. It’s briny with a strong nose of olive and nail polish. Those notes carry throughout, but there are added herbal notes that round out the taste in a pleasant way.

ManuelP

ManuelP

51 reviewsUSA
9.5/10

Extremely elegant version of the wild olive brine direction rum can go. Wow. Also strong nail polish remover. Also I’m shocked this is a molasses column still. World upside down.

Tomáš Jankovský

Tomáš Jankovský

42 reviewsUSA
7.7/10

A very fragrant funky rum with an interesting taste and aroma. Pleasant to taste.

Doctor Luke

Doctor Luke

15 reviewsUSA
8.6/10

A beautiful rum, one of the most beautiful and unique bottles in the US market. Incredibly loud olives and brine - almost a dirty martini in a bottle, but with a lemon twist. Indeed I've gone through two of these bottles by having it made into a martini by skilled bartenders. Yes, a rum martini. But this is the one you can do it with without being completely insane. It expands your imagination as to what rum can be.

Ian Gilman

154 reviewsUSA
7.0/10

My second Grand Arôme (after the Aficionados Le Galion) and my first taste of Savanna. I do prefer the meatier profile and finish of the Le Galion to the cough syrup-y notes of the Savanna. I love the intensity and that you can smell this bottle across the room, but upon revisiting this bottle, the medicinal and industrial notes are overwhelming. I like when those flavors compliment something else but aren’t the focal point. Not a bad price point but doesn’t compare to La Galion.

Rob Balazs

Rob Balazs

6 reviewsUSA
8.3/10

So nice to see a Grand Arôme in the states! Nose is fruity, tropical, with a funky, nutty(?) note that is hard to place. Palate is full of overripe tropical fruit, and fleeting mint or menthol? I could very much see adding this to a Jamaican rum for a Mai Tai

Benjamin Campbell

4 reviewsUSA
7.7/10

Enjoyed with Eric at the ORS event. Truly spectacular.

Kieron Wood

Kieron Wood

468 reviews
10.0/10

Rumfest 2023 tasting so notes were brief One of the best samples at the event

Richard Colwell

33 reviewsUSA
5.5/10

Strong nose with notes of olive, brine, solvents, varnish, leaning in the sour direction. The palate is similar to the nose with mild sweetness and intense chemical notes and sourness. Finish is lasting, towards a metallic aftertaste. Definitely an opinionated, interesting rum, but not for everyone.

Kevin Sorensen 🇩🇰

Kevin Sorensen 🇩🇰

7,408 reviewsDenmark
8.8/10

#5394 13.06.2025 Enjoying a few samples to the beats of Psy-Fi Festival 2025. Nose Fresh, medium intense, fruity, light berries, light citrus, sugarcane, faint plastic. Palate Fresh, medium intense, fruity, naturally sweet, light metallic, olive, light mint, faint salt, light mango, cherry, light floral. Finish Long and warm, fruity, light citrus, light anise, berries. Empty glass Citrus, light licorice, light manto, light strawberry, faint metallic.

Beancheese

Beancheese

103 reviewsCanada
7.0/10

What a wild ride this rum is. Right away the nose hit me with olive brine and nail polish remover, so much so that I almost couldn’t get past it. I could try to find other notes hiding behind there but it was just so overwhelmingly true to those two items that it felt like I was ‘trying’ to find something more. Both of these notes hold true and dominate on the palate as well, although this funky rum has a bit more going on. Behind the salty olive brine and acetone there was also permanent marker, a bit of something peaty or smoky, some mild licorice like spice. This was a wildly interesting way to sample my first rum from Reunion but I would never catch myself drinking this as a regular sipper. I think an imaginative mixer could make great use of this in a cocktail however and it is perfect for nerding out. I will score it 6.5 because it’s just not my palate if I was looking for something to enjoy sipping - but it’s so curious and fun that the ‘experience’ of trying it could be 8+

RumCzar

RumCzar

42 reviewsUSA
5.0/10

This rum was a huge disappointment. I heard great things about the Grand Arome, and I thought it would compare favorably to Jamaica hogo, but the Grand Arome is way to savory for me. It's flavor reminds me of hot dogs and pickles and witch hazel. That's not a flavor I want from my rum. Sorry folks! I won't rebuy.

Tried it already?

Rate this rum in the RumX app and help others choose.

Rate it in the app

Expert reviews

Reviews from independent critics who have tasted this rum.

Community shelf

26 of 39 bottles are still sealed.

  • 26 sealed
  • 11 open
  • 2 emptied
  • 39 bottles on the shelf, owned by 37 members
  • 35 tastings
  • 11 wishlists

Members paid a median of 49 €.

The middle 80% of purchase prices were between 45 and 58 €.

14 purchases by 12 members since July 2023. Self-reported and unverified, not a shop price.

Full price history in RX+

Reported by RumX members from their collections · as of How these numbers are made

Details about Holmes Cay Savanna Réunion Island Grand Arôme Rum No. 3 2023

A White Rum from Reunion, bottled by Holmes Cay, at 57,5%.

Origin

DistillerySavannaover 330 rums on RumX · avg 8.3/10 from 8,833 ratings
CountryReunion
BottlerHolmes Cay

Production

Raw materialMolasses
DistillationSavalle Still
AgeUnaged

In the bottle

ABV57,5%
Volume75cl
Bottled2023
Limited editionYes
CategoryWhite Rum

Read on in the RumX Guide

You may also enjoy

Members who rate this rum highly often rate these highly too.

Discover more alternatives

Shopping safely on RumX

Your retailer delivers. We are here to help.

The retailer named in the offer is your seller and ships your bottle. You order and pay here on RumX. Our team helps you resolve questions with the shop.

Help with your order
Oliver, founder of RumX

Oliver GerhardtFounder of RumX, Stuttgart

“I started RumX in 2018 as a rum fan and I still build it myself today. If something is wrong with your order, write to us. No call centre will answer, but my small team or me.”
As featured in
Stern Stuttgarter Zeitung Rumporter fizzz About Drinks
All press coverage

Any questions before you buy?

Who sells and ships the bottle?

The retailer named in the offer is your seller and ships your bottle. You order and pay here on RumX. Our team helps you resolve questions with the shop. Help with your order

Is shipping included in the price?

When shipping costs for your destination are known, we show the total and break out the bottle price and shipping. Change the delivery country in the offer to see the applicable price. View offer

Can I return the bottle?

Your purchase contract is with the shop, so returns and cancellations run through them under their own policy and your statutory rights. If anything goes wrong, RumX helps you sort it out.

Are the reviews from buyers?

Reviews are from RumX community members. A purchase through RumX is not required. The overall score is the median of the ratings. Rating scale & review checks

Price alerts · in the RumX app
Never miss a price drop.

Set a target price in the app, and we'll let you know as soon as the rum becomes available at that price from one of our partner stores. This works for any rum on your wish list.

★ 4.8/5 on App Store & Play Store
Rating guide

Every score is the median of members’ ratings, from 0 to 10. A 7 is already a recommendation to buy.

Share of 11,355 rums with at least 4 ratings, calculated on November 20, 2026. Scale and calculation in detail