Aroma visualization from community tastings
Forgotten Gems Caroni Traditional Column Rum
Dark, tarry Caroni that drinks better than it looks
Less suitable for newcomers — one taster found Caroni too extreme
Offers & prices
Returns & cancellation
- Your purchase contract is with the shop, so returns and cancellations run through them under their own policy and your statutory rights. If anything goes wrong, RumX helps you sort it out.
- Secure payment.
You pay via RumX with PayPal, Klarna or card. Your payment data is encrypted and we never store your full card details.10 more payment methods
- Help from RumX. Questions about your order? Write to us. We sort it out with the shop, whichever one you ordered from.
Price history
Currently unavailable
Delivery to
You'll get an email as soon as a shop delivers it.
Buying advice
These ship to you
Rums in a similar style that ship to you.
Similar in style and available now.
This bottle

Forgotten Gems Caroni Traditional Column Rum
Fruitier8.9 instead of 8.5
Fruitier
ClarendonDistilia Clarendon Finest Jamaican Rum (Rhum Attitude & Bar Lamp) 1995
8.9/10 (71 reviews)Too few members have rated both rums so far.
Milder8.6 instead of 8.5
Milder
CaroniCane Rum Bottling Company Caroni Single Cask Rum 1998
8.6/10 (35 reviews)Too few members have rated both rums so far.
Is it your taste?
How does Forgotten Gems Caroni Traditional Column Rum taste?
Dark, tarry Caroni that drinks better than it looks
"I was really prepared for this to be horrible," one member admits — that near-black colour scares everyone off before the first sip. But the glass tells a calmer story: tar, wet oak and menthol up front, ripe yellow fruit and a touch of burnt sugar underneath. At 61.2% the alcohol sits surprisingly well integrated. Not peak Caroni, but a decent, balanced pour once you get past the look.
Style & occasion: Mature & oakySipping neat
From community reviews · summarized with AI
How much rum experience do you have?
Rather demanding for you
Fit for you: Rather low
This rum’s experience level: Connoisseur. It can be demanding as a first step.
Depends on your taste
Fit for you: Medium
This rum’s experience level: Connoisseur. It can be demanding as a first step.
Very likely your rum
Fit for you: Very high
This rum’s experience level: Connoisseur. That matches your level.
If you already know Caroni's tar-and-diesel signature, this is a fair, balanced example worth trying — several members flag the near-black colour and quietly question it, so buy with eyes open.
More precise with the Match Score in the appCaroni fans chasing tar and menthol
newcomers — one taster found Caroni too extreme
The aroma profile in detail Nose and palate from 6 detailed tastings
| Aroma | On the nose | On the palate | On the finish |
|---|---|---|---|
| Funk 34% of mentions | |||
| Tar | 5 | 6 | 4 |
| Glue | 3 | 2 | not mentioned |
| Wood & roast 25% of mentions | |||
| Woody | 2 | not mentioned | 4 |
| Oak | 3 | not mentioned | not mentioned |
| Tonka bean | 2 | 2 | not mentioned |
| Spice 14% of mentions | |||
| Licorice | not mentioned | not mentioned | 4 |
| Vanilla | not mentioned | 2 | not mentioned |
| Fruit 9% of mentions | |||
| Citrus | not mentioned | not mentioned | 1 |
| Vegetal 7% of mentions | |||
| Menthol | 3 | 4 | not mentioned |
| Sweet 3% of mentions | |||
| Sweet | not mentioned | 2 | not mentioned |
| Tropical 2% of mentions | |||
| Tropical fruits | 2 | not mentioned | not mentioned |
| Other | |||
| Warm | not mentioned | 2 | 1 |
Also mentioned: Fruit schnapps 1, Minty 1, Roasted 1
What does the community say?
14 community reviews
100% rate it “Good” or better.
Rating scale & review checks
On RumX, 7 means “Good” and 8 means “Very good”. See the full rating guide
How ratings are made and how we check themWhat members praise Tar and menthol · Integrated 61% · Long licorice finish
What bothers them Alarming dark colour · Not peak Caroni · Oaky, wet-wood nose
Summarised from the tasting notes
7 selected written reviews
The distribution above includes all 14 ratings, including those without text.
At first I was worried that I had a beast in my glass. Because of the totally black color, of course. As you might expect, the rum is very dark in flavor. Intense wood and roasted aromas, but there is still some fruit to be found.
Color is of course total crap, but the taste is quite solid. Regular Caroni without much excitement.
A very dark color, reminiscent of 1993's "The Beast". The nose is marked by wet wood, tar aromas and yellow fruit alcohol. Some fruit in the background too. The palate is much better than the nose, still with overripe apple alcohol, but also a slight menthol and maritime tar (from the deck of a ship). The wood, very present on the nose, is much more discreet here. The finish is long, as you'd expect from a Caroni, with pronounced aromas of sweet wood (licorice) that lend an almost sweet edge that's very pleasant. The empty glass sent me to an old wooden building that had suffered the ravages of time in the tropics. The color of this rum was a little frightening, as was its nose (too marked by damp wood), but in the end it's a Caroni, admittedly special, but quite good. I loved its chewy woodiness, which took me back to my childhood.
Archetypal HTR aromas surrounded by some wood, dark spices and a hint of burnt sugar. The alcohol is impressively well integrated. Not a monster of complexity, but a thoroughly harmonious, balanced, continental Caroni. The question remains as to the cause of the color - and whether everything went according to plan here. In terms of taste, a subtle (!) "recalibration" cannot be completely ruled out in my opinion, but that is of course purely speculative.
The color suggests nothing good... But in fact, the nose and palate reveal mild, typical 98 bourbon notes. I like it very much! Would be very interesting to find out more about the vintage and the small number of bottles!
#7573 07.11.2026 Enjoying some samples while listening to some nice Armin van Buuren tracks on Spotify. Very nice Caroni that had a good price tag at release in my mind. Medium intense profile with roasted wood, fruits, spice, tar, mint, licorice and some natural sweetness.
Krogulczyk
Its my first Caroni, and i think i need more time with getting used to it’s characteristics. I love Haiti and Jamaica but Caroni is just too extreme for me. I will edit that review someday
Tried it already?
Rate this rum in the RumX app and help others choose.
Expert reviews
Reviews from independent critics who have tasted this rum.
I was really prepared for this to be horrible. Especially the colour suggested more The Beast suffering. It also is not able to reach Caroni excellence, but it is really okay at the end. We have seen much worse! Worth a try for the prize of the most mysterious caroni bottling :P
Live auctions
A bid is not a final price: the house sets the buyer's premium, shipping and any customs duty.
Community shelf
6 of 6 bottles are still sealed.
- 6 sealed
- 0 open
- 0 emptied
- 6 bottles on the shelf, owned by 5 members
- 14 tastings
Reported by RumX members from their collections · as of How these numbers are made
Details about Forgotten Gems Caroni Traditional Column Rum
A rum from Trinidad, bottled by Forgotten Gems, at 61,2%.
Origin
Production
In the bottle
Read on in the RumX Guide
You may also enjoy
Members who rate this rum highly often rate these highly too.

Bristol Caroni Haromex 1998

The Little Distiller Caroni Ultimatum Rum HTR 1998

CDI Caroni Trinidad 1998
Discover more alternatives

Caroni S.B.S Trinidad HTR 1997

Nobilis T.D.L No. 27 2001

CDI T.D.L Trinidad (Premium Spirits) 2003
Shopping safely on RumX
Your retailer delivers. We are here to help.
The retailer named in the offer is your seller and ships your bottle. You order and pay here on RumX. Our team helps you resolve questions with the shop.
Help with your order
Oliver GerhardtFounder of RumX, Stuttgart
“I started RumX in 2018 as a rum fan and I still build it myself today. If something is wrong with your order, write to us. No call centre will answer, but my small team or me.”

Any questions before you buy?
Who sells and ships the bottle?
The retailer named in the offer is your seller and ships your bottle. You order and pay here on RumX. Our team helps you resolve questions with the shop. Help with your order
Is shipping included in the price?
When shipping costs for your destination are known, we show the total and break out the bottle price and shipping. Change the delivery country in the offer to see the applicable price. View offer
Can I return the bottle?
Your purchase contract is with the shop, so returns and cancellations run through them under their own policy and your statutory rights. If anything goes wrong, RumX helps you sort it out.
Are the reviews from buyers?
Reviews are from RumX community members. A purchase through RumX is not required. The overall score is the median of the ratings. Rating scale & review checks

Forgotten Gems Caroni Traditional Column Rum
Set a target price in the app, and we'll let you know as soon as the rum becomes available at that price from one of our partner stores. This works for any rum on your wish list.
