Aroma visualization from community tastings
Hemingway Rum Papa's Pilar Dark Rum
Most tasters land on "sweet and easy" here, though a few find it thin or too sugary. Expect caramel, vanilla, chocolate and dark sugar up front, with cinnamon and a little spice behind it. The 43% shows through with a light burn some notice on the tongue. One reviewer calls it a "great sipper"; others just wanted more depth.
The community says- Caramel-vanilla profile
- Easy casual sipper
- But: Contains added sugar
View price history
10 more payment methodsSecure payment Sold by Bondston Returns & cancellation
- Secure payment. You pay via RumX with PayPal, Klarna or card. Your payment data is encrypted and we never store your full card details.
- Clear seller. Sold and shipped directly by the partner shop. And you're never on your own: RumX handles support and communication with the shop, so you always get excellent service, whichever shop you order from.
- Honest shop ratings. The stars show your service experience with the shop, not the rum score. They come from RumX users, and critical ones stay visible.
- Returns & cancellation. Your purchase contract is with the shop, so returns and cancellations run through them under their own policy and your statutory rights. If anything goes wrong, RumX helps you sort it out.
Buy Hemingway Rum Papa's Pilar Dark Rum:
Compare all 3 shop offers
Prices & availability last updated on
The look inside the bottle
How does Hemingway Rum Papa's Pilar Dark Rum taste?
Aggregated from 77 community reviews.
Sweet, dessert-leaning dark rum for casual sipping Well-liked by sweet-rum drinkers for its caramel-chocolate-vanilla profile. The catch: several find it a touch too sweet, thin, or a little hot, and the finish runs short.
People who like sweet, easy dessert-style sippers and bourbon fans easing into rum
Anyone avoiding sugar or wanting a dry, complex rum
How the community classifies this rum. Each category takes you to similar rums.
Which glass for which rum? The community guide →
19 of 77 left detailed tasting impressions · Click an aroma to explore similar rums
Recommendation
Your next rum
One difference each to this rum.
Rated better
Mount Gay XO - Triple Cask Blend
7.8/1041 €
Milder
A.F.D. Patridom Seleccion Exclusiva
7.3/1027 €
Similar rating, cheaper
Chairman's Reserve Original
7.1/1025 €First choice: 23 of 28 tasters who tried both prefer it.
How is Hemingway Rum Papa's Pilar Dark Rum rated?
RumX’s 0–10 scale is strict: 7.4 sits in the “Good” band. 64% of tasters rate it Good or better; only 7% rate it below average. See the full rating guide →
Community voices
What does the community say?
65% rate it between 6 and 8. 17 selected write-ups from 77 community ratings. You can view the complete list in our app.
Review by Business Liner Ralf
Most helpful positive review
Addendum: today in the Friendsgiving round on the Tisvj H: unanimous opinion: great rum and perfect bourbon finish. Never drunk before! I am an absolute rum lover. But as a bourbon fan, it's a great tribute to Hemmingway as a rum. My absolute favorite at the moment!
Review by crazyforgoodbooze
Most helpful critical review
Again, quite thin, alcoholic and quickly gone. Toffifee with a little raisin and banana.... Unimportant, unfortunately.
Review by Stefan Persson
Tasted this one at a rum cruise at the Baltic Sea. Nice bottle and story around it. It’s quite sweet, but the 43% ABV makes it balanced. The representative told me it was a blend consisting of rum aged between 4 and 25yo.
Review by BTHHo 🥃
The taste burns a little on the tongue at first. It's sweet, but not as sweet as the scent. You can taste caramel, cinnamon, dark sugar, vanilla, licorice and a little oak. Medium aftertaste. A good relaxed rum, especially for lovers of sweeter rums. It’s quite smooth and good for casual sipping.
Review by Timo Groeger
Day trip Baltrum September 2024. Sturm-Eck pub. Good rum selection for an average pub ;-) This one is too sweet for me. Nose consists of caramel, chocolate and coffee. Then chocolate, vanilla and spices on the palate. Average.
Review by Michael Ihmels 🇩🇪
The last rum on Baltrum for today. The Papas Pilar from the United States. Already very sweet on the nose and this is also reflected in the taste. Nevertheless, all in all, it is good to drink
Review by Jon Stover
Smells like brown sugar and vanilla. Lighter not overly boosy. Tastes brown sugar vanilla and earth. No spice. Sweet on front end& light/butter. Caramel on back end.
Review by Rafael Gonzalez
I guess i just got a sweet tooth.it all comes to personal taste.not sure since im new to this but is there a standard to what a great rum should taste like?anyway i loved the variety of tastes i got from this guy and i honestly enjoyed it.i get some people dont like the sweet in some things but i really liked it
Review by Thomas
Bought directly on Key West. There on vacation he tastes better with Bob of course, but a tasty rum without edges. Quite short finish, unfortunately.
Review by Peter Sjoroos
Better than expected. Not over sweetened and with some nice mix of caramel and spices.
Review by Goodoboy30
This is really good. Slightly sweet. Great sipper.
Review by Valeri Karsten
Preis-Leistung stimmt bei diesem Solera-Rum auf jeden Fall. In der Nase sehr vielversprechend, ein tolles Bouquet aus Süße, Vanille, Karamell und Komplexität. Die 43% sind aber sowohl und der Nase als auch später im Geschmack merklich spürbar. im Nachgang vielleicht mehr flüchtig, als man erwarten würde, dennoch sehr empfehlenswert.
Review by Kay Meertens
Raisin, vanilla, orange
Review by Matej
Un unexpected gift from my university teacher. I really do like the shape of this bottle and the story of Pilar boat is very interesting. Aroma itself is very sweet, almost christmasy (chocolate, sugar and caramel with lot of spice). I noticed very intensive orange, cinamon and some herbs. Taste is very simillar to aroma. Sweet, lot of cinamon, orange and chocolate. I noticed lot of spice, but unfortunately the whole experience is ruined by the unpleasant alcoholic taste. Finish is short and it feels like you just ate the whole box of chocolate pralines (not bad thing at all). For me this rum will be good as part of some christmasy drink or as an ingredient of some sweets.
Review by Michael Janek
ve vůni cítím.teply kakao ta vůně je opravdu velmi intenzivní a dlouho trvajici chuť je příjemně nasladla, kakaová, jemně šimrajicí
Review by Kamil Čmiel
For me, nicer packaging than the inside of the bottle. A little sharper finish. Otherwise, for the price, it's certainly not a bad rum.
Review by 86kringo
Schöne runder einfacher rum mit viel vanille
No reviews match this filter.
Expert reviews
Reviews from RumX's blog partners, independent experts who have tasted, evaluated, and described this rum..
Expert review by The Fat Rum Pirate
Read full review →The Cola and Dr Pepper references have been to often and any rum which tastes like a carbonated fruit flavoured soda is going to be very divisive. I just don't get this rum and I doubt many will. It's not unpleasant as such just very, very strange........
Live auctions
Current bids for this rum at Europe's leading auction houses.
Market value
Avg. community purchase price 37 €
What members paid for this bottle, self-reported. Not a market value — the purchases are over three years old at the median and unverified.
Details about Hemingway Rum Papa's Pilar Dark Rum
A Column Still Rum from USA, bottled by Hemingway Rum, at 43%.
Community purchases
77 bottles logged by 72 collectors.
A drinker & collector.
27% opened, 6 emptied and repurchased.
What does Hemingway Rum Papa's Pilar Dark Rum cost?
Community paid 6–54 €.
Current best price: 35.94 € – within the typical community range.
What members actually paid for their bottles. A typical range, not the current shop price. Full price & collection history in RX+ →
77 purchased · 84 tasted · 20 wishlist · as of
Read on in the RumX Guide
You may also enjoy
Rum enthusiasts who like this rum have also given the following rums high ratings:
Brugal 1888 Doblemente Añejado
Brugal 1888 Doblemente AñejadoSherry-and-oak Spanish sipper, lightly sweet
Hemingway Rum Papa's Pilar Sherry Finish
Hemingway Rum Papa's Pilar Sherry FinishSweet, raisiny sherry-cask everyday sipper
T.D.L Zaya Rum Gran Reserva
T.D.L Zaya Rum Gran ReservaSweet vanilla-chocolate dessert sipper for beginners
Cartavio XO
Cartavio XOSoft, sweet Spanish-style sipper with nutty depth
DDL El Dorado 15
DDL El Dorado 15Sweet, caramel-rich Demerara starter sipper
Dictador 20 Years
Dictador 20 YearsSweet coffee-and-chocolate sipper, thin body
Never miss a price drop.
Set a target price in the app, and we'll let you know as soon as the rum becomes available at that price from one of our partner stores. This works for any rum on your wish list.
Oliver · FounderBy rum lovers, for rum lovers
I'm Oliver, and RumX began in 2018 as a small passion project in Stuttgart, back then under the name Rum Tasting Notes.
What began as my digital tasting diary is now the world's most comprehensive platform for rum fans, today carried by a small team with Jakob, Lukas and Katharina, with Robert supporting us as a freelancer. We combine the collective intelligence of our community with an integrated marketplace, so you can choose with confidence, without paperwork, detours, or expert jargon.
Oliver, Stuttgart
About RumX →YouTube channel (in German)
