
Taste
Smoky, Tar, Leather
Most mentioned across 27 tasting notes
- Perfect for
- peated-whisky fans and smoke lovers
- Less suitable for
- anyone chasing fruity, easygoing rum
Chairman's Reserve Master's Selection (Renbjer Fine Spirits 20th Anniversary 2004-2024) 2009
Smoky, tarry pot-still that drinks like peated whisky
Less suitable for anyone chasing fruity, easygoing rum
Offers & prices
Returns & cancellation
- Your purchase contract is with the shop, so returns and cancellations run through them under their own policy and your statutory rights. If anything goes wrong, RumX helps you sort it out.
- Secure payment.
You pay via RumX with PayPal, Klarna or card. Your payment data is encrypted and we never store your full card details.10 more payment methods
- Help from RumX. Questions about your order? Write to us. We sort it out with the shop, whichever one you ordered from.
Price history
Currently unavailable
Delivery to
You'll get an email as soon as a shop delivers it.
Buying advice
These ship to you
Rums in a similar style that ship to you.
Similar in style and available now.
This bottle

Chairman's Reserve Master's Selection (Renbjer Fine Spirits 20th Anniversary 2004-2024) 2009
Sweeter8.1 instead of 8.2
Sweeter
MHOBAMHOBA Umbila Bourbon Cask (LMDW New Vibrations Collection) 2023
8.1/10 (45 reviews)Too few members have rated both rums so far.
Fruitier8.3 instead of 8.2
Fruitier
IsautierSwell de Spirits Isautier Wild Nature Series 2011
8.3/10 (70 reviews)Too few members have rated both rums so far.
Milder8.4 instead of 8.2
Milder
Rum ArtesanalEnmore Rum Artesanal Guyana Rum MEV 1990
8.4/10 (49 reviews)Too few members have rated both rums so far.
Is it your taste?
How does Chairman's Reserve Master's Selection (Renbjer Fine Spirits 20th Anniversary 2004-2024) 2009 taste?
Smoky, tarry pot-still that drinks like peated whisky
Not what anyone expects from Saint Lucia — tar, cold smoke and leather dominate, with earth and rubber close behind. Several members reach for whisky comparisons (Islay, Lagavulin) rather than rum, and one calls it "smoky/tar/earthy" before the fruit even shows. Ripe fruit and dry caramel sit underneath if you give it time. At 60.5% it needs air and a few drops of water to fully open.
Style & occasion: Mature & oakySipping neat
From community reviews · summarized with AI
How much rum experience do you have?
Rather demanding for you
Fit for you: Rather low
This rum’s experience level: Expert. It can be demanding as a first step.
A good match for your level
Fit for you: High
This rum’s experience level: Expert. That matches your level.
A good match for your level
Fit for you: High
This rum’s experience level: Expert. That matches your level.
Hand this to a friend who drinks Islay whisky and watch them puzzle over the label. Give it a good hour of air and a splash of water before you judge it — several members found it grew on them each pour.
More precise with the Match Score in the apppeated-whisky fans and smoke lovers
anyone chasing fruity, easygoing rum
The aroma profile in detail Nose and palate from 27 detailed tastings
| Aroma | On the nose | On the palate | On the finish |
|---|---|---|---|
| Wood & roast 36% of mentions | |||
| Smoky | 70 % | 74 % | 15 % |
| Leather | 33 % | 67 % | not mentioned |
| Nutty | 33 % | 33 % | not mentioned |
| Roasted | not mentioned | 33 % | 19 % |
| Woody | not mentioned | 33 % | 15 % |
| Funk 18% of mentions | |||
| Tar | 63 % | 52 % | not mentioned |
| Rubber | not mentioned | 33 % | not mentioned |
| Petrol | 30 % | not mentioned | not mentioned |
| Vegetal 17% of mentions | |||
| Earthy | 56 % | not mentioned | 15 % |
| Vegetal | 41 % | not mentioned | not mentioned |
| Peat | not mentioned | not mentioned | 22 % |
| Fruit 12% of mentions | |||
| Fruits | 30 % | not mentioned | not mentioned |
Also mentioned: Medicinal 19 %, Tropical fruits 19 %, Metallic 15 %
What does the community say?
41 community reviews
93% rate it “Good” or better.
Rating scale & review checks
On RumX, 7 means “Good” and 8 means “Very good”. See the full rating guide
How ratings are made and how we check themThe most helpful voices
The review with the most helpful votes in each rating group. The distribution above shows how often each score was given.
Positive voice
LukaŽigahas rated 1,562 rums · Germany
9.1/10
9,1:On the nose, this rum is really complex and like a poetry, we get smoky dried and yellow fruits with apricots, maybe peaches, the molasses is herbal, minty, there are juicy, estery tropical fruits with mango and the wood is charred with caramel and roasted nuts. Balanced like a poem. On aeration, some industrial notes arise with rubber, maybe even tar, vegetal like tea, tobacco, sap and after well rest, peat.Defintely, there are some apple, banana, grape and prunes, very tasty with a combination of charred and vegetal notes. 9,1:On the palate, the attack is with smoky fruits like mango, maracuja, banana and charred wood notes like roasted nuts, dark chocolate, caramel, leather and a pinch of rubber. It is spicy with cardamom, red bell peppers, vanilla and earthy, dry and very round, especially when yellow fruits are added.Another layer of fruit notes are citrus and ripe strawberry with creamy vanilla. There are delicious honey marshmellows.Molasses is minty with tea.If we wait, there is coconut coming from underneath. 9:The finish is also tasty and balanced with the notes from palate lingering and also a new layer of notes like bacon, wax and tannins, we shall not forget Tiramisu.... Very complex and delicious.Top!😋 Edit:29.8.25, 9.10.26
44 found this helpful · Oct 2026
All 17 positive reviewsMixed voice
zabohas rated 2,021 rums · Germany
7.9/10
Edit Edit: Somehow, the more I try it, the better I find it. A wacky piece that is atypical of Chairman's, yet extremely interesting, but still too close to a whisky Edit: For me, a Chairman's outside the range I was used to, but not really bad either, just different. You have to get used to it first. Also somehow tasted a minty note after taking a longer breath. Totally confusing. I'll hold off on the rating until the samples are out. My tip is to give your dram plenty of time first. I'll add my notes soon.
39 found this helpful · Oct 2024
All 8 mixed reviewsCritical voice
Thunderbirdhas rated 1,401 rums · Germany
5.4/10
Well, this bottling doesn't really have anything to do with a Chairman's anymore. It reminds me more of a Scottish peaty whisky... with a little burnt caramel and roasted nuts. It obviously seems to be an experiment and has gone wrong for me. The whisky influence is too strong, especially in the finish.
26 found this helpful · Oct 2024
All 2 critical reviews27 selected written reviews
The distribution above includes all 41 ratings, including those without text.
Would never have guessed a Chairman's here. I really like the intensity on the palate. This rum comes with a lot of pleasant warm dirty power on the palate, somehow earthy, astringent, maritime and rusty. The finish runs very metallic-citrus fruity. The alcohol could be better integrated. Totally interesting Chairman's. Tastes are debatable, this rum here has a lot of potential for debate. I find it successful and without the finish it would have gotten more points here.
The nose starts unusually: dry dusty – somewhat reminiscent of gentian. Actually, it fits gentian quite exactly. Smells like French gentian liqueur (Suze or Salers). Underneath lie caramel, wood, dried fruits, some smoke, lots of vegetal notes, and after a while also some (mainly continental) fruit. The dusty hay-like vegetal gentian note is also back on the palate. Definitely an unusual Chairman’s and worthwhile for all who can be happy beyond fruitiness. I actually like it.
Sample poured. At first a strong tar hits the nose. St. Lucia, really? Fruit is actually rather in the background in this bottling. It is more spicy-herbaceous with notes of rubber, smoky to charred. It doesn't seem very round but somehow unusual which makes this bottling really exciting.
In my opinion, a rather atypical Lucia. I miss the tropical ester fruit notes. Instead, there are far too many slightly peaty whisky notes for my taste. It seems a little young overall. Alcohol could be a little better integrated. After an hour in the glass, the rum opens up, but overall it's still not quite my cup of tea.
Overall a very special and in my opinion quite fantastic rum with Laphroaig vibes. This very special Master’s Selection from SDL and Chairman’s Reserve is celebrating the 1st 20 years of Renbjer Fine Spirits. The specialness is that it’s 50/50 John Dore 2 and Vendome which is a blend I’ve never heard of before. The nose gives you aromas of fruits and leather but above all it’s smoky with a scent of tarred rope. At the palate and during the long finish comes the aromas and scents back as flavors together with honey and some notes of rubber, bourbon and oak.
Ha! That's supposed to be a St. Lucia? Is it even a rum or a whisky? Seriously, it is a rum and a good one at that, but a profile I would never have expected from a Chairmen’s. Smoky, earthy, peaty, dirty. But on the nose still with nice fruit that I can't quite pinpoint 100%. Dried plum with maraschino…
Caroni meets Jamaica? Exciting bottling from St. Lucia, which keeps producing good and very good stuff. A very fruity nose, where I even find some esters, but they are heavily embedded in dirty notes of tar, gasoline, and rubber. On the palate, these aromas dominate and get reinforced by wood, smoke, and roasted notes. After some time, also a bit of mint; blind, I would have placed it as Trinidad! Even though the St. Lucia character shines through, it's a rather unusual bottling. But not bad at all!
Very smoky nose. Has something metallic even. Also a good load of wood on the nose. On the palate further lots of smoke and tar. Almost a bit too much for me. Not quite my guy, the mate. Doesn't make the 8.
The Renbjer definitely is an outlier… there is lots of smoke and tar on the nose alongside a weird vegetal note. On the palate much more akin to other SLD pot still bottlings. Still has some whisky vibes and not much fruits to it. An interesting odd ball, I guess?
Rarely had a rum in the glass that was so hard to describe in taste. Additionally, the rum tasted completely different on two different days. So here's an attempt at an approximation: some smoke, herbs, and nutty notes. In my view, the rum leans more towards whisky. At a blind tasting, that would certainly be very exciting. Alcohol well integrated. If possible, definitely try it. However, I wouldn't chase a bottle.
Nils123
With water it becomes really smoky and dirty.
Stefan L
I like it a lot and it is really heavy! It blooms out a little extra smokyness with a few drops of water. 😋A fantastic job by Renbjer! - 260109: Quite some time later. This really is in the extreme end(in a good way) and I applaud Renbjer for having the guts to release something like this.
rbfsnow
😍Love or 🤮Hate Chairmans Reserve with a "smooky" Lagavulin taste in my opinion.
This is really a very interesting rum. On the nose first cold smoke, behind that the typical St. Lucia profile, with rather low esters. On the palate first the analogous smoky note, then something floral (Serge’s description of gentian schnapps fits very well), plus caramel (not the sticky kind, but dry and with fine sweetness and spice) and cask. A slight astringency fits very well into the profile and concentrates the aromas. On the finish then again the smoky note paired with caramel and cask. I’m really not a fan of smoke, but here it gives the rum an interesting touch. Impressively shows the range of this distillery, although as a confessed St. Lucia fanboy I might not be completely objective. In any case an exceptional rum that one should at least try once.
Today again a Chairman from St Lucia. Basically I am a huge fan of this distillery, but this bottling only pleases me to a limited extent. After 20 minutes in the air, there is an intense but quite bitter taste on the nose and palate that I don't really like. However, the alcohol is very well integrated.
Positive surprise from the house of Saint Lucia. The nose slightly reminds me of a Herr... at least the fruity fermented note. On the tongue there is fruit and wood. Unfortunately the finish is not so long. Still a very nice super
Exciting rum! Very floral spicy nose, Serge talked about gentian – I don't know it, but that's how I imagine it. Slightly phenolic, somehow going towards Islay malt at the back of the nose. Very interesting! On the tongue, light hints of autumn fruits, pear, apple, plum. Drifts on the palate into a medicinal direction, a bit like surgical cleaning agents. The alcohol is well integrated but still prominent enough to convey an overall cheeky, dirty character. Great drop!
Smoky, earthy, peaty, herbal. Reminds me more of a Scotch. Underlying rum comes through, interesting but strange.
This is exactly the kind of rum you either love or hate. What's the reason? Smokiness... And I love it! Dark red color and full aroma immediately reveal earthy scent and taste of red fruit, which quickly turns into technical notes, leather, smoke/tar. You can clearly recognize the John Dore 2 distillation technique. If you like smokiness like me, you'll be very happy, if not, better avoid it.
Dave Dahlgren
Burns but quite pleasant, a bit more farmyard
Claes Nilsson
Lots of smoke on the nose, reminds me more of a peaty whisky than rum I think. A bit of fruitiness in the background though. Smoke also when I taste, more rum-like, strong but not a very long aftertaste. Since I don't like the smoky character, it lowers the rating.
Emanuel S
This is an experience. A very complex rum in my opinion. It might remind you of peated whisky but this is far from what comes out of Islay. The aroma/flavor profile is similar in that is smokey/tar/earthy. But then this takes a turn. Its fruity, with hints of apple and tropical fruits. It has rubber and petrol. Its nutty. Tobacco can be found. The finish is long with earthy/Smoky tones taking the lead with dried fruit and burnt sugar backing it up. I get a bacon vibe too. Very strange. Its complex. I can sit with this for hours just smelling it. It takes time to open up so dont rush it. At 60% it packs a punch. In my opinion, adding a bit of water makes it better.
Perfect when you're outside grilling. Flavorful. A bit smoky. Absolutely wonderful when the food isn't too strong 😋
Motvind
Nah, this wasn't for me. A hint of caramel scent breaks through the heavy smells of smoke, leather, and earth. I can't distinguish any of the sweetness in the taste. The heavy flavors completely take over and are, in my opinion, a bit too much.
9,1:On the nose, this rum is really complex and like a poetry, we get smoky dried and yellow fruits with apricots, maybe peaches, the molasses is herbal, minty, there are juicy, estery tropical fruits with mango and the wood is charred with caramel and roasted nuts. Balanced like a poem. On aeration, some industrial notes arise with rubber, maybe even tar, vegetal like tea, tobacco, sap and after well rest, peat.Defintely, there are some apple, banana, grape and prunes, very tasty with a combination of charred and vegetal notes. 9,1:On the palate, the attack is with smoky fruits like mango, maracuja, banana and charred wood notes like roasted nuts, dark chocolate, caramel, leather and a pinch of rubber. It is spicy with cardamom, red bell peppers, vanilla and earthy, dry and very round, especially when yellow fruits are added.Another layer of fruit notes are citrus and ripe strawberry with creamy vanilla. There are delicious honey marshmellows.Molasses is minty with tea.If we wait, there is coconut coming from underneath. 9:The finish is also tasty and balanced with the notes from palate lingering and also a new layer of notes like bacon, wax and tannins, we shall not forget Tiramisu.... Very complex and delicious.Top!😋 Edit:29.8.25, 9.10.26
Edit Edit: Somehow, the more I try it, the better I find it. A wacky piece that is atypical of Chairman's, yet extremely interesting, but still too close to a whisky Edit: For me, a Chairman's outside the range I was used to, but not really bad either, just different. You have to get used to it first. Also somehow tasted a minty note after taking a longer breath. Totally confusing. I'll hold off on the rating until the samples are out. My tip is to give your dram plenty of time first. I'll add my notes soon.
Well, this bottling doesn't really have anything to do with a Chairman's anymore. It reminds me more of a Scottish peaty whisky... with a little burnt caramel and roasted nuts. It obviously seems to be an experiment and has gone wrong for me. The whisky influence is too strong, especially in the finish.
This selection contains no written reviews in this rating range.
Tried it already?
Rate this rum in the RumX app and help others choose.
Live auctions
A bid is not a final price: the house sets the buyer's premium, shipping and any customs duty.
Community shelf
13 of 24 bottles are still sealed.
- 13 sealed
- 5 open
- 6 emptied
- 24 bottles on the shelf, owned by 18 members
- 41 tastings
- 3 wishlists
Members paid a median of 80 €.
The middle 80% of purchase prices were between 77 and 95 €.
Full price history in RX+Reported by RumX members from their collections · as of How these numbers are made
Details about Chairman's Reserve Master's Selection (Renbjer Fine Spirits 20th Anniversary 2004-2024) 2009
A Pot Still Rum from Saint Lucia, distilled by Saint Lucia Distillers, at 60,5%.
Origin
In the bottle
Read on in the RumX Guide
You may also enjoy
Members who rate this rum highly often rate these highly too.

MHOBA Indlovu Bourbon & Brandy Casks (LMDW New Vibrations Collection) 2023

Chairman's Reserve Master's Selection (The Nectar 15th anniversary) 2005

Chairman's Reserve Master's Selection (6. Rum & Co) 2004
Discover more alternatives

Chairman's Reserve Master's Selection (German Edition) 2005

Chairman's Reserve Master's Selection (Wu Dram Clan) 2009

TRC South Pacific Fiji 2003
Shopping safely on RumX
Your retailer delivers. We are here to help.
The retailer named in the offer is your seller and ships your bottle. You order and pay here on RumX. Our team helps you resolve questions with the shop.
Help with your order
Oliver GerhardtFounder of RumX, Stuttgart
“I started RumX in 2018 as a rum fan and I still build it myself today. If something is wrong with your order, write to us. No call centre will answer, but my small team or me.”

Any questions before you buy?
Who sells and ships the bottle?
The retailer named in the offer is your seller and ships your bottle. You order and pay here on RumX. Our team helps you resolve questions with the shop. Help with your order
Is shipping included in the price?
When shipping costs for your destination are known, we show the total and break out the bottle price and shipping. Change the delivery country in the offer to see the applicable price. View offer
Can I return the bottle?
Your purchase contract is with the shop, so returns and cancellations run through them under their own policy and your statutory rights. If anything goes wrong, RumX helps you sort it out.
Are the reviews from buyers?
Reviews are from RumX community members. A purchase through RumX is not required. The overall score is the median of the ratings. Rating scale & review checks
Chairman's Reserve Master's Selection (Renbjer Fine Spirits 20th Anniversary 2004-2024) 2009
Set a target price in the app, and we'll let you know as soon as the rum becomes available at that price from one of our partner stores. This works for any rum on your wish list.