Aroma visualization from community tastings
TOP 5 Rums that make a BETTER Mai Tai than APPLETON!
15 NEW Rum Releases from Holmes Cay, Appleton, Santa Teresa and more!

Taste
Caramel, Woody, Dried fruit
Most mentioned across 32 tasting notes
- Perfect for
- fans of warm spice and sweetness who want a stronger pour
- Less suitable for
- navy purists after a dry, robust, austere profile
- How to drink
- Neat and in cocktails
Planteray Mister Fogg Navy Rum (No. 1) 2024
Spiced, sweetish navy blend for winter evenings
Less suitable for navy purists after a dry, robust, austere profile
Offers & prices
Returns & cancellation
- Your purchase contract is with the shop, so returns and cancellations run through them under their own policy and your statutory rights. If anything goes wrong, RumX helps you sort it out.
- Secure payment.
You pay via RumX with PayPal, Klarna or card. Your payment data is encrypted and we never store your full card details.10 more payment methods
- Help from RumX. Questions about your order? Write to us. We sort it out with the shop, whichever one you ordered from.
Price history
Currently unavailable
Delivery to
You'll get an email as soon as a shop delivers it.
Buying advice
These ship to you
Rums in a similar style that ship to you. The head-to-head only counts members who rated both rums.
Similar in style and available now.
Alternative rated higher rated the same this rum rated higher
This bottle

Planteray Mister Fogg Navy Rum (No. 1) 2024
Fruitier8.2 instead of 7.7
Fruitier
Multi DistilleriesVelier Papalin Haiti 2023
8.2/10 (131 reviews)
25 members rated bothMostly rated higher
25 rated both: 21 scored it higher, 3 scored Planteray higher, 1 gave both the same score.
Drier7.5 instead of 7.7
Drier
PlanterayPlanteray Mister Fogg Navy Rum (No. 2) 2025
7.5/10 (88 reviews)Too few members have rated both rums so far.
Milder7.9 instead of 7.7
Milder
PlantationPlantation Barbados One-Time Limited 20 2013
7.9/10 (68 reviews)Too few members have rated both rums so far.
Is it your taste?
How does Planteray Mister Fogg Navy Rum (No. 1) 2024 taste?
Spiced, sweetish navy blend for winter evenings
This one is for anyone who likes a rich, sweetish rum with real strength behind it. Cinnamon and clove lead, over dried fruit, caramel and a streak of dark chocolate, and the proof drinks gentler than you would expect. Many here find it closer to Christmas spice than a classic navy rum, which suits a cold evening or a Mai Tai.
Style & occasion: Mature & oakySipping neatCocktails & mixing
From community reviews · summarized with AI
Aroma profileHow much rum experience do you have?
Depends on your taste
Fit for you: Medium
This rum’s experience level: Explorer. It can be demanding as a first step.
Very likely your rum
Fit for you: Very high
This rum’s experience level: Explorer. That matches your level.
Depends on your taste
Fit for you: Medium
This rum’s experience level: Explorer. With more experience it often feels simpler.
A good bridge for someone used to sweet rums who wants to step up in strength: the spice and caramel feel familiar, and the proof barely bites.
More precise with the Match Score in the appfans of warm spice and sweetness who want a stronger pour
navy purists after a dry, robust, austere profile
Frequently mentioned aromas
Mostly Sweet, with Spice.
- On the nose
- Woody Tropical fruits Dried fruit Caramel
- On the palate
- Caramel Woody Dried fruit Tropical fruits
From 32 detailed tastings
The aroma profile in detail Nose and palate from 32 detailed tastings
| Aroma | On the nose | On the palate | On the finish |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sweet 31% of mentions | |||
| Caramel | 44 % | 69 % | not mentioned |
| Sweet | 34 % | 38 % | 19 % |
| Molasses | not mentioned | 38 % | 22 % |
| Honey | not mentioned | 28 % | 31 % |
| Caramelized | 25 % | not mentioned | not mentioned |
| Spice 19% of mentions | |||
| Baking spices | not mentioned | 38 % | not mentioned |
| Clove | 31 % | not mentioned | 16 % |
| Cinnamon | 22 % | not mentioned | 22 % |
| Wood & roast 15% of mentions | |||
| Woody | 56 % | 50 % | 25 % |
| Dried fruit & cask 12% of mentions | |||
| Dried fruit | 47 % | 50 % | not mentioned |
| Tropical 10% of mentions | |||
| Tropical fruits | 50 % | 38 % | not mentioned |
| Fruit 9% of mentions | |||
| Orange peel | not mentioned | not mentioned | 22 % |
Also mentioned: Banana 19 %
Finish: medium, in 14 of 20 entries.
What does the community say?
63 community reviews
87% rate it “Good” or better.
Rating scale & review checks
On RumX, 7 means “Good” and 8 means “Very good”. See the full rating guide
How ratings are made and how we check themWhat members praise Christmas spice · Value for money · Integrated alcohol
What bothers them Noticeably sweet · Atypical for navy · Short finish
Summarised from the tasting notes
The most helpful voices
The review with the most helpful votes in each rating group. The distribution above shows how often each score was given.
Positive voice
Palo - V Pohárikuhas rated 132 rums · Slovakia
8.5/10
Impressive navy-style rum from Planteray! Interestingly, from the taste and aroma, I would have guessed that the biggest portion of the blend is DDL. However, according to official information, the dominant component is WIRD. On the nose, woody notes dominate, accompanied by hints of dark dried fruit, banana peel and burnt caramel, which give it a robust, slightly roasted profile. The palate reveals an interesting mix of molasses, dried fruit, and wood, balanced with subtle black pepper and a faint touch of citrus. The finish is medium-long, carrying forward notes of woody oak, molasses, and a pleasant hint of honey, intertwined with lingering orange peel and banana. This rum is well-rounded yet still retains that bold navy strength. A solid 8.5/10 for me!
14 found this helpful · Sep 2024
All 9 positive reviewsMixed voice
zabohas rated 2,021 rums · Germany
7.0/10
Edit: after standing a little in the open bottle of Split, I think it has degraded quite a bit. The artificial notes are now more apparent. Corrected downwards. Pure it is surprisingly better than expected. I thought I wouldn't like it at all. It's nothing special, but you can use it as a cheap rum in a Lumumba, I think it's well suited for that. The dosage doesn't dominate that much either.
39 found this helpful · Jan 2025
All 22 mixed reviewsCritical voice
JFehrhas rated 191 rums · Germany
4.5/10
Sweetish, medicinal and quite boring. Very pleasant, very slight bitterness. Quite cinnamony
12 found this helpful · Jan 2025
32 selected written reviews
The distribution above includes all 63 ratings, including those without text.
@BCB Berlin: Basically not a bad rum, but somehow I miss the balance here. Acidity, wood, sweetness, fruit and tannins come together here without really coming together. The 5g dosage is also absolutely unnecessary for such a product in my opinion. I'll have to take another look at it...
I found the background to Mr. Fogg very interesting and moving. That's why I was already looking forward to this rum. On the nose, it is reminiscent of apple strudel, stewed plums and winter spices (gingerbread). Similar on the palate. A pleasant entry-level sipper, but for me it doesn't really have much in common with a (good) navy rum.
I think it's important to remember with this rum that the primary goal here was not to create a good rum, but to faithfully replicate rum as it was once made. And the story is compelling. And the rum itself is certainly not bad!
7,8:On the nose, flowery molasses, soap, then winterly ambient with roasted wood notes like nuts, dark chocolate, caramelized sweet spices like clove, cinnamon, metallic patina, cherries and rubber, bump into our nosetrils. On aeration, dried, tropical and citrus fruits are out, some candied, earthy molasses with tobacco, dark with black tea, various delicious notes if pastry, biscuits, some allspice. 7,5:On the palate, the attack is winterly with various roasted wood notes like pastry, caramel, biscuits, dark chocolate, leather, spicy with baking spices, peppery, fruits like pineapple, cherries, citrus and dried fruits, sweet molasses with honey, earthy and red wine, slightly synthetic, when the rum is oxidized. 7,6:The finish is medium long, dry&tannic, still sweet and winterly with notes from palate lingering on. Edit:14.3.26
Navy rum that is really fun. Only the dosage spoils the great story somewhat.
#6776 10.05.2026 Relaxing with a few samples after getting back from a nice dinner in Flensburg. Listening to some tracks by Sub6 and olly James on Spotify. First off the price quality performance (release price) is very good in my mind. A nicely balanced and notes of molases, fruits, chocolate and some sweetness in the spicy palate.
And my favorite for today, one more to come, let’s see. Finally you can feel the ABV, tropical and dried fruits here, plus sweetness from honey and caramel, also slightly woody.
Gregor
Crazy what Plantation has done again. Unbeatable value for money. Lots of Jamaican influence. Nice tropical fruits with some esters. Because of the value for money, you should definitely try it at least once.
Masterclass V&B December 2, 2025. 👃 Very light esters of a fruit liqueur. Tropical fruits (flambéed banana and pineapple) and dried fruits. Spicy and vanilla wood, a bit chemical, heated sugar, a soft caramel liqueur side, kitchen spices. 😋 Lots of spices, obvious vanilla side, cinnamon, dried fruits, tropical fruits flambéed with sugar, sweetness and roundness of caramel (you can feel a bit of added sugar) which allows a very good integration of the alcohol. Impression of wine cask. ⛳ Quite short I find compared to the ABV. Spices, wood, astringency. Sweet combination of banana, candied orange, honeyed and syrupy molasses. 💡 A simple and accessible blend. Low-cost Navy Rum slightly sweetened that allows to "handle" the 55° rather easily. Recommended to discover this type of English Rum.
OK, after the first tasting I deliberately didn't create a rating. I was still too busy brushing my teeth. After a week, I tried it again. Today it's only bad, the first time it was still disgusting. Too sweet, too Christmassy and spicy, more "rum-based spirit" than rum. Luckily, I got the sample before I fell for the bottle.
Amazing aroma. The scent offers notes of caramel, dried fruit, cherries, and wood with a subtle caramelized sweetness. The taste is rich in tropical fruits, citrus, and pineapple, complemented by a sweet honey touch and delicate hints of red wine. The finish is full, fruity, and harmoniously sweet.
Very much covers all expectations I have when tasting a navy rum. The blend is very well executed delivering on dark notes, dried fruits and Christmas spices. Overall I the taste gives the impression that the components aren’t too old. But given the price point this is fair. There is a hint of „too sweet“ for me, but it is very much ok and the added sugar is not overwhelming.
RumMyWay
Warm yet smooth! Spicy on initial taste but smooths very quickly with a nice warmth in the chest! Nice medium finish with a dark chocolate lingering that is very pleasant. Olive and dried fruits on the nose. Big fan of this Rum and it packs a cool story! Definitely a keeper in the collection
I've been looking for an affordable (in the sense of around 50 euros) and good navy rum for my tasting for a long time. This one actually comes pretty close to that. On the palate I have dried fruit, black pepper and hints of red wine. The alcohol is not perfectly integrated and is clearly noticeable on the tongue. I'm still pleasantly surprised.
🥃 Plantation Mister Fogg Navy Rum 2024: A disappointment due to a disturbingly artificial note. Given the hype of the last two years, I expected more. But to taste again in another context ...
Smell is pretty rich here. Apricot and plum. Some oak, maybe. Cough medicine from the Mauritius element. Dried fruit, some wood. Pours dark golden. A little tar, burnt tire in your mouth from Trini element. A little overripe banana. Some more cherry cough syrup. A little sweet, probably dosed since it's Plantation. Still, among the better Plantation I've had. Nice Navy blend. Bottle.
Not a typical navy profile. Relatively mild, somewhat sweet, especially cinnamon and Christmas spices. Relatively alcoholic on the finish. I don't quite understand the bottling. A good blend, but in my eyes it has absolutely nothing to do with a navy rum.
Ok schöne Geschichte, die Dosage trübt diese aber (zumindest für mich etwas) Nase ist einfach, sehr fruchtig, süßlich, Karamell vielleicht auch marzipan. Geschmack ist fruchtig süß, etwas Gewürz (Nelke) und leichter Pfeffer. Abgang dann sehr viel Honig, Nelke und Karamell. Alkohol ist recht gut eingebunden. Süffig aber nicht besonders.
Tasted at GRF2025 Although its dosed, very good price quality balance. I have to admit, now that Planteray is more transparent on the content of their rums (leaving the discussion if it's forced or not) I do appreciate the brand a lot more.
First version of the Planteray Navy Blends after I recently had the 2025 in the glass. This one smells a bit sweeter, a bit musty comes after a few minutes. On the palate lots of cinnamon, a bit winey and citrus fruits. Clearly less balanced than its successor, which I should taste again calmly.
Mark Leggett
Smells really good, caramel, dark fruit, a little smoke and a hint of funk. Taste follows the smell and being navy strength really gives it punch
Boy was I looking forward to this! Navy-Blend recreation from a mighty (too mighty?) Barbadian player? Historical background and research by the one and only Wonk? But let's not get ahead of ourselves. Colour: light tawny Nose: Initial impression from the fresh sample was "Dominosteine?" (that chocolate covered triple layer sweets of marzipan, jelly and gingerbread). The rested sample is lighter, less jelly and fruity but still sweet, Christmas spice and white chocolate Taste: I can't wrap my head around how christmas-y it tastes. Sweet, cinnamon-clove mix, milk chocolate, powdered sugar. Finish: Still sweet, christmas bells still ringing. Verdict: I don't know. This doesn't taste like Navy to me. This is a sweet Christmas-themed spiced rum. I don't see how this is supposed to be historically accurate. Unless the British Navy was made up of Santa and his elves (turns out Matt was only responsible for the book part?!). What a let down (it's not "bad", but it's not what the story was trying to sell, imho). Pusser's Dockyard feels more Navy that this.
While I was positively surprised by the first sip, the rum gets worse with every sip: the strong cinnamon note increasingly takes over, Guyana and Barbados flash repeatedly. In the end, baking spices and a sweet artificial note dominate. For me, this has nothing to do with Navy Rum. The slight alcoholic sharpness suggests that these are rather young distillates. Possibly interesting in cocktails or to introduce sweet rum fans to non-sweet rums.
The nose and front taste are great, but it's just cloyingly sweet which kills it for me as a sipper. Makes a great mai tai.
Feels fairly balanced, a bit of sweetness. Doesn't drink at its proof. Think it works better in a cocktail as opposed to a sipper, but solid all around
Typical Jamaican rum with an intense smell that doesn't linger very long on the palate. But for this price, completely fine.
Not a very interesting rum, I see it more as an attempt to create something than a rum I would want to savor.
So many cherries, but from where...?
Anonymous
It would be a premium mixer rum. Straight or neat, might not be in my top 10.
Palo - V Poháriku
Impressive navy-style rum from Planteray! Interestingly, from the taste and aroma, I would have guessed that the biggest portion of the blend is DDL. However, according to official information, the dominant component is WIRD. On the nose, woody notes dominate, accompanied by hints of dark dried fruit, banana peel and burnt caramel, which give it a robust, slightly roasted profile. The palate reveals an interesting mix of molasses, dried fruit, and wood, balanced with subtle black pepper and a faint touch of citrus. The finish is medium-long, carrying forward notes of woody oak, molasses, and a pleasant hint of honey, intertwined with lingering orange peel and banana. This rum is well-rounded yet still retains that bold navy strength. A solid 8.5/10 for me!
Edit: after standing a little in the open bottle of Split, I think it has degraded quite a bit. The artificial notes are now more apparent. Corrected downwards. Pure it is surprisingly better than expected. I thought I wouldn't like it at all. It's nothing special, but you can use it as a cheap rum in a Lumumba, I think it's well suited for that. The dosage doesn't dominate that much either.
Sweetish, medicinal and quite boring. Very pleasant, very slight bitterness. Quite cinnamony
This selection contains no written reviews in this rating range.
Tried it already?
Rate this rum in the RumX app and help others choose.
Expert reviews
2 independent critics have tasted and scored it.
Read full reviewThis rum should appear here next year and I estimate the price should be between 50 and 80 Euros, which is a great price for such a rum. It’s a good and honest rum and I think many people will like it. I like it too and can recommend it.
Tasting videos · 2
Live auctions
A bid is not a final price: the house sets the buyer's premium, shipping and any customs duty.
Community shelf
50 of 66 bottles are still sealed.
- 50 sealed
- 9 open
- 7 emptied
- 66 bottles on the shelf, owned by 49 members
- 66 tastings
- 30 wishlists
Members paid a median of 49 €.
Today about below what the community paid.
The middle 80% of purchase prices were between 31 and 50 €.
Full price history in RX+Reported by RumX members from their collections · as of How these numbers are made
Details about Planteray Mister Fogg Navy Rum (No. 1) 2024
A Pot & Column Still Rum from Multiple countries, bottled by Maison Ferrand, at 55,7%.
Origin
Production
In the bottle
Read on in the RumX Guide
You may also enjoy
Members who rate this rum highly often rate these highly too.

Swell de Spirits Easy Peasy Series (Exotic Blended Rum)

Pusser's Rum Deptford Dockyard Reserve

Travellers Planteray Belize One-Time 2008
Discover more alternatives

TCRL T.D.L Trinidad #27 2006
Shopping safely on RumX
Your retailer delivers. We are here to help.
The retailer named in the offer is your seller and ships your bottle. You order and pay here on RumX. Our team helps you resolve questions with the shop.
Help with your order
Oliver GerhardtFounder of RumX, Stuttgart
“I started RumX in 2018 as a rum fan and I still build it myself today. If something is wrong with your order, write to us. No call centre will answer, but my small team or me.”

Any questions before you buy?
Who sells and ships the bottle?
The retailer named in the offer is your seller and ships your bottle. You order and pay here on RumX. Our team helps you resolve questions with the shop. Help with your order
Is shipping included in the price?
When shipping costs for your destination are known, we show the total and break out the bottle price and shipping. Change the delivery country in the offer to see the applicable price. View offer
Can I return the bottle?
Your purchase contract is with the shop, so returns and cancellations run through them under their own policy and your statutory rights. If anything goes wrong, RumX helps you sort it out.
Are the reviews from buyers?
Reviews are from RumX community members. A purchase through RumX is not required. The overall score is the median of the ratings. Rating scale & review checks

Planteray Mister Fogg Navy Rum (No. 1) 2024
Set a target price in the app, and we'll let you know as soon as the rum becomes available at that price from one of our partner stores. This works for any rum on your wish list.



