320,000+ honest rum ratings Europe’s largest rum selection: 6,600+ rums RumX app: 4.9 out of 5 on the App Store

320,000+ honest rum ratings

They come from members of the RumX app, not from us or the shops. Moderators, community reports and automated checks keep them clean. The score is the median.

How the score is made

Europe’s largest rum selection: 6,600+ rums

From 40+ specialist shops in one place, all ready to order right here. When several shops carry the same rum, we sort by total price including shipping to your country.

View all rums

RumX app: 4.9 out of 5 on the App Store

On Google Play 4.7 out of 5. In the app you rate rums yourself, and from your fifth rating on the Match Score shows which rums suit you.

Get the RumX app

Rum for whisky fans: which rum matches your whisky

Jack Daniel's, Glenfiddich 12, Macallan 12 and Lagavulin 16: for each one a rum where you'll find what you love about your whisky

8 Nov 2026
11 min read
Oliver Gerhardt at a table with a nosing glass, a bottle of Jack Daniel's and a bottle of Doorly's 14

You drink whisky and want to try rum? Then first ask yourself what you love about your whisky: the wood, the fruit, the sherry or the smoke. For each of these there’s a rum where you’ll find exactly that. I took four well-known whiskies, Jack Daniel’s, Glenfiddich 12, Macallan 12 Sherry Oak and Lagavulin 16, and searched 119,151 tastings on RumX for the rums where you tick the same aromas.

Here’s the video, and below it everything to read up on.

Love whisky? These rums match Jack Daniel's, Macallan and Lagavulin

Which rum matches which whisky?

The short version, with the details for each pairing further down:

Your whiskyWhat you love about itYour first rum
Jack Daniel’s Old No. 7Wood, vanilla, caramelDoorly’s 14, cheaper: Mount Gay XO
Glenfiddich 12Fruit, pearWorthy Park Single Estate Reserve
Macallan 12 Sherry OakSherry, dried fruitAbuelo XV Oloroso
Lagavulin 16SmokeChairman’s Reserve Vintage 2009, wilder: River Antoine Rivers

For each whisky I took the aromas the distillery itself lists and looked at which rums get exactly those ticks far more often than average. The ticks show you where an aroma is. Whether you’ll like the rum, they don’t say. That’s why each rum also comes with how it’s rated.

What's an aroma tick?
When you rate a rum on RumX, you can tick aromas such as vanilla, pear or smoke. “Nine times as often” means this rum gets that tick in nine times as many tastings as the average rum. It shows where an aroma is, not whether you'll like the rum.
Where do the numbers come from?
As of October 30, 2026: 305,011 valid tastings on RumX excluding swipe ratings, 119,151 of them with aroma ticks. Scores are medians; the values on the rum pages keep updating and may differ. Paired comparisons only count people who rated both bottles, not blind. Whisky aromas are taken from the producers.

What’s the difference between rum and whisky?

Mostly the raw material. Whisky is distilled from grain, rum from sugar cane, usually from molasses, the dark syrup left over when sugar is made. In the cask, the two are closer than many people think: lots of rums mature in barrels that used to hold American whiskey, the very barrels that matter most for Scotch, too.

Two things really set them apart:

  • Sugar. In the EU, whisky can’t be sweetened. Rum may contain up to 20 grams of sugar per litre, and the label usually doesn’t say so.
  • Peat. The smoke in Scotch comes from the peat fire the malt is dried over. Sugar cane isn’t malted, so rum doesn’t bring peat smoke by itself.

They’re old friends all the same. Around 1800, a gentlemen’s club in Glasgow held rum punch to be the drink of choice. The money behind it came from the sugar and rum trade with the Caribbean, which was built on the labour of enslaved people.

Is rum sweeter than whisky?

Not all of it, but the best-known ones often are. The three most-rated rums on RumX are the Diplomático Reserva Exclusiva, the Planteray XO (formerly Plantation) and the Zacapa 23. All three are fairly heavily sweetened. They aren’t bad rums, lots of people love exactly this mellow style. Even among our connoisseurs, a good four in ten started with a sweetened rum like that. So did I, by the way: I started with the Diplomático.

If you’re used to whisky, you’ll often find this style too sweet. Brown-Forman, the company behind Jack Daniel’s, paid more than 700 million dollars for Diplomático in 2023. Of 211 people who rated both the Diplomático and the unsweetened Doorly’s 14, nine in ten gave the Doorly’s the higher score.

And taste shifts with experience. Take the people on RumX who have rated several sweetened and unsweetened rums: among those with fewer than 50 rums, just under a third prefer the dry ones. From 250 rums on, it’s almost all of them. So dry rum isn’t a niche thing; for those who’ve tried the most, it’s the norm. As a whisky fan, you can skip that detour.

Four whiskies, four rums

Which rum suits Jack Daniel’s?

The Doorly’s 14 from Barbados, if what you love about your Jack is the wood and vanilla. According to the producer, Jack Daniel’s tastes of vanilla, caramel and oak. That comes from the cask: in Tennessee, the whiskey has to mature in new, charred oak barrels, and fresh wood gives off a lot of vanilla and caramel. Afterwards the barrels are sold on, and Scotch or rum very often matures in them.

On RumX there’s an aroma tick simply called “Bourbon”. You set it when a rum reminds you of that American style. Strictly speaking, Jack Daniel’s isn’t a bourbon but a Tennessee whiskey; the tick means exactly that style, though. The Doorly’s 14 gets it nine times as often as average. It comes from the Foursquare distillery, matures for 14 years in the tropics, mostly in barrels that used to hold American whiskey, and isn’t sweetened at all. Two thirds give it at least an 8.

“Personally too bitter and woody for me. Still good quality. Definitely one for whisky lovers.” (from a RumX rating, translated)

Too pricey for a first try? Then go for the Mount Gay XO, also from Barbados and noticeably cheaper. It gets the Bourbon tick six times as often as average, too.

Which rum suits Glenfiddich 12?

The Worthy Park Single Estate Reserve from Jamaica, if what you love about your Glenfiddich is the fruit. Glenfiddich describes its 12-year-old as fresh and fruity with a hint of pear, plus butterscotch and a touch of oak. The pear doesn’t come from the cask but mostly from fermentation: the yeast produces compounds that smell of pear and banana. The same thing happens in rum, especially in Jamaica.

The Worthy Park Single Estate Reserve gets the pear tick almost five times as often as average. The British magazine Decanter recommends exactly this rum to fans of Speyside whiskies, the region Glenfiddich comes from. It isn’t sweetened. Two differences you should know: at 45 % it’s a bit stronger than the Glenfiddich, and, typical for Jamaica, there’s a lot of banana in it; that’s even its most frequent tick.

I’m a big fan of the Worthy Park house style myself. And Glenfiddich knows the two go together: according to Glenfiddich, its 21-year-old finishes in casks that used to hold Caribbean rum.

Which rum suits Macallan 12 Sherry Oak?

The Abuelo XV Oloroso from Panama, if what you love about your Macallan is the sherry. The Macallan 12 Sherry Oak matures in casks that used to hold sherry, wine from Jerez in southern Spain. Macallan has the casks built in Spain and filled with sherry for months before the whisky goes in. According to Macallan, it tastes of dried fruit, ginger and oak spice.

The obvious pick would be the Brugal 1888: Edrington, the company behind Macallan, holds the majority of Brugal from the Dominican Republic, and the 1888 also finishes in sherry casks. The ratings see it differently. Of 21 people who rated both the Brugal 1888 and the Abuelo XV Oloroso, not a single one gave the Brugal the higher score. To be fair, though: the Brugal costs about half as much.

The Abuelo XV Oloroso finishes in casks that held Oloroso, a dry, nutty sherry. It gets the sherry tick almost thirty times as often as average. Two things you should know. According to the producer, the “XV” means “up to 15 years”; on Scotch, that number would be the minimum age. And there’s some sugar in the Abuelo: a retailer says so and many of you note it, but the producer doesn’t say how much. People who otherwise prefer dry rums still give it a strong 7.9.

“Matured in sherry casks, and you can really taste it.” (from a RumX rating, translated)

Which rum suits Lagavulin 16?

The Chairman’s Reserve Vintage 2009 from Saint Lucia, if what you love about your Lagavulin is the smoke. This is the hardest one. Lagavulin describes its 16-year-old with peat smoke, iodine, seaweed and salt. Malt dried over a peat fire doesn’t exist in rum, so you have to look for the smoke elsewhere.

You call the Chairman’s Reserve Vintage 2009 smoky six times as often as average. It spent eleven years in ex-bourbon barrels. Where exactly the smoke comes from, the distillery doesn’t say; it writes about smoky leather and dark chocolate itself.

“Quite smoky, towards charcoal. Then you’d think it was somehow salty. Scotch fans would surely like it.” (from a RumX rating, translated)

And if you like it really wild, have a look at the River Antoine Rivers from Grenada. At River Antoine, a water wheel has driven the cane mill since the 1840s, and the stills are heated directly by fire. It has 69 % and is very highly rated. I’d rather put it in a Daiquiri than pour it on your first evening with rum, though.

Is there smoky rum?

Yes, but the smoke almost never comes from peat. The obvious idea is a rum that finishes in an Islay whisky cask. Planteray (formerly Plantation) did that with a rum from Guyana: twelve months in the cask of a peated Islay whisky. On RumX it sits at 6.8 out of 10. One rater from Sweden sums it up: “Twelve months in an Islay cask, that’s eleven too many.”

It isn’t a one-off. I looked at the 87 people who mention Islay, smoky whiskies or peat in their notes and have rated rums from peated whisky casks. For almost nine in ten of them, these rums score below their other rums on average, 7.3 against 8.2. The other way round works, by the way: in 2024, Lagavulin finished a whisky in Caribbean rum casks for a little over eight months.

So where is the smoke in rum? You tick “smoky” noticeably more often than average on rums from Trinidad and Saint Lucia. On Jamaica only as often as average, even though you write “whisky” in your notes particularly often for the Hampden 8.

Two rules for your first rum

  1. Check whether there’s sugar in it. The label usually won’t tell you. On RumX, rums without added sugar are collected under Unsweetened.
  2. A whisky cask on the label doesn’t mean you’ll like it. Rums from peated casks do worse with Islay fans in particular, see above.

Whether a specific rum suits you is what the Match Score estimates. You rate a few rums in the RumX app, and it looks at how people with similar taste rated other rums. Every rum page also shows what the bottle currently costs in the price comparison.

And if you’re the rum person and someone in your family loves whisky: with the table above, your gift list is done.

Which whisky is yours, and what do you love most about it? Tell me under the video on YouTube and I’ll find you a matching rum.

FAQ: rum for whisky fans

Just like your whisky: neat, at room temperature, from a nosing glass. With cask strength, a few drops of water help. Which glasses work best is in the glass guide.

Ask which whisky they drink first, then pick the matching rum from the table above. If you don’t know, I’d go for the Doorly’s 14: it isn’t sweetened and tastes of ex-bourbon casks, which almost every whisky fan knows.

Not by default. In the EU, whisky has to be at least 40 % ABV, rum at least 37.5 %. Most of the aged rums in this article sit between 40 and 48 %, the same range as typical single malts. Both come at cask strength too; the River Antoine Rivers has 69 %.
Share